Sometimes 1+1 does not = 2.

Recently, a friend and I were having a conversation about my journey of faith. She said the predictable, logical conclusion someone might draw from my experience in an abusive, controlling church would be that I lost my faith.

She said it would be as simple as 1+1=2. Girl is born into cult + Girl watches cult implode= Girl loses faith in God.

Indeed, some might say that's the only intellectually honest conclusion.

We ended up having a great conversation and it got me thinking about why I didn't lose my faith. And today I was inspired by Rachel Held Evans' post "Breaking The Cycle of Cynicism."

So, here's my answer:

I knew some people who rationalized my intact faith by saying: 1. She's an anomaly–the "margin of error" that must be figured into statistical evidence; or 2. that she was so severely brainwashed she couldn't bring herself to abandon the final vestiges of comfort afforded by organized religion.

I don't think either of these rationalizations pertain to me. For one thing, I've been evaluated by a therapist and she informs me that yes, I've sustained trauma but no, I'm not psychotic. Phew! Glad we got that outta the way!

I'm a clear thinker, apparently. Despite my "inferior female mind." Har har.

I suppose the very predictability of the 1+1=2 equation saved my faith. Here's why: I could see how the flawed hierarchy in my church, the nepotism, the misuse of tithe monies and the lack of transparency and accountability all contributed to the downfall of its leader.

Something didn't add up and that something had nothing to do with God.

I also knew the leader personally. Heck, he was my grandfather! Let's just say that while he may have entertained delusions of grandeur, I realized by my late teens that he was nothing more than a little old man hiding behind the curtain and pretending to be The Great & Terrible Oz.

Of course, I had no hard evidence. But that all came in time.

The point is, it would have been intellectually dishonest of me to abandon my faith in God based on false representation by a flawed human being.

Still, after I left the church, I was sorely tempted to believe what others said about God. This played straight into my insecurity. I had such a hard time believing that God really loved me that I was easily rattled by a grim theology that insisted God hated me.

I was scared they might be right.

I decided to find out for myself Who God was. The more I came to grow in my relationship with Him, the less I cared about how other mis-portrayed Him.

There will always be those who bring shame to Christ's name. That's been happening since He ascended. Of course, it's much sadder when Christians do this. I had to learn (the hard way) that it wasn't my job to go around convincing everyone that they were wrong about Him.

My job was/is to simply love God and love others. Pretty simple, really. But not easily done! However, the more I threw myself into loving my husband, serving my family and being a good, kind neighbor–the more happy and peaceful I became.

Grief and loss are opportunities to find healing and new life. The more I turned inward (self-pity, cynicism, bitterness), the less peaceful I was. The more I turned outward (serving, loving, giving), the more my happiness grew. In fact, it grew exponentially!

Love + Hope= Faith

For me, that was an equation that actually worked.

Does that make sense?

This entry was posted in Faith, RecoveringFundamentalist. Bookmark the permalink.
  • Valerie

    I think that speaks to your strength of character, Elizabeth, and the fact that you were willing to move past the hurt and the pain to find Him as He really is. One of the things that breaks my heart is to see a generation of older folks – say, 50 plus – who have been wounded by the church at some point (I see that hand!) and still live out of that place of hurt and bitterness. The wound becomes the paradigm and they carry a chip on their shoulder forever, amen. I am NOT discounting pain and betrayal, but I am saying that living out of that place forever will get you nowhere. They stay in a place of immaturity, feeling justified in bitterness and rejection. There are a lot of wounded babies of all ages running around.

    It takes guts and humility to move out of a place of brokeness and into a place of submission to Jesus, allowing Him to heal and restore and renew. There are so many people I LONG to see moving forward and kicking some serious butt in the Kingdom. So many precious souls wasting away who could be living the abundant life. I hate that.

    What I see in you is that you separated the church from the Man and moved on from there.

  • Rachel

    “Something didn’t add up and that something had nothing to do with God. ”

    Exactly! I see we share more than a common grandfather. ;-)

    It was the same for me. The realization of how human all of the abuse and darkness of our past was only strengthened my faith in God.

    The more I realized that the humans of our past (grandparents, etc.) were following terribly predictable human patterns with the predictable terrible outcome, the more I realized that none of it had anything to do with God.

    This in spite of desperate insistence by everyone around us.

    It thrilled me to realize that loving God, believing in God, didn’t require subjecting myself to ongoing abuse or require me to abuse others.

    The logical conclusion that God was not in that abusive situation prompted me to look for what was God. Even though my journey has taken me to an externally different place, the interior conclusion is the same: true faith = love + hope. “By this will all men know that you are my disciples, that you love one another.”

  • Michelle Hart

    once again, something i needed to hear today. it gives me hope for my own faith experience, that all is not lost. there truly can be “beauty from ashes.”

  • Charis

    I ended up at that same place: loving God and loving others… which I figure will keep me busy enough for the rest of my life!

  • http://www.heidijowhatdoyouknow.blogspot.com Heidi Jo

    of course it does. and it is the rationale that more of us need to take when something ‘implodes’ in our churches…instead of running.

    our faith is not in people. our faith is not in teachings that change with the culture. our faith is not in who sits beside us.

    my faith is in who i receive each and every week that i am there.

  • http://www.10minutewriter.com Katharine

    Man! I cannot WAIT to read your book!

  • http://hilluponhill.blogspot.com/ hill upon hill

    Boy you have written this well and boy (again) you have come through to a great and mature understanding of faith. Wonderful.

  • http://www.aholyexperience.com Ann @ Holy Experience

    “My job was/is to simply love God and love others.”

    Yes. Yes, yes, yes.

    Reading your faith journey enlightens mine.

    Thank you, E.E….
    All’s grace,
    Ann

  • Charlie Moore

    I agree with you there Liz. I am another example of someone not loosing faith because of a cult. And we know plenty more who came out of that place and are still going strong for the Lord. It is awesome to see that you are doing well and have a servants heart toward your family and others. I can see that you are truly blessed by God.

    Charlie

  • http://www.rachelheldevans.com Rachel H. Evans

    Thanks so much for the shout-out, and for the FANTASTIC comment you left on my blog.

    What a great post. My favorite quote:

    “…After I left the church, I was sorely tempted to believe what others said about God. This played straight into my insecurity. I had such a hard time believing that God really loved me that I was easily rattled by a grim theology that insisted God hated me…I was scared they might be right.”

    I’ve added you to my Google Reader and will be back again FOR SURE! Thanks for your inspiring words.

  • Rachel

    Oh, is this what your book is gonna be about? In that case….I can’t wait.

    I did wonder about this -how you still have a relationship with God, but I guess I also wondered if you still have a relationship with your grandfather and/or father. (Sorry if I’m stepping on toes.)

  • http://www.morningstarr.typepad.com Dina

    Just followed your link to Rachel Held Evans blog. Love the tough questions she asks and the thorough research she delves into in a quest for the truth. Thanks for sharing!

  • http://www.suburbancorrespondent.blogspot.com suburbancorrespondent

    Saying that you should have lost your faith in God because you were in a dishonest, abusive church is not a forgone conclusion at all. You understood that you had experienced a perversion of something that was actually good and true; you hadn’t experienced the real thing at all. Why wouldn’t that conclusion be as logical as the other one?