Historical Accurassy

After suffering a minor physical breakdown last week, I fled to the bookstore. Because this is how I drown my sorrows: in the pages of a book.

And it would have been perfect  if not for the noisy meeting of Future Bestselling Authors Who Wear MuMus Covered In Cat Hair. They had spread their fat massuscripts all over the middle of the coffee shop and were criticizing each other's work at full volume.

YOU CAN'T FEEL YOUR TEARS IF YOU'RE UNDERWATER! I MEAN, WHO DOESN'T KNOW THIS??

I hazarded a glance at the poor old lady whose novel-in-progress was being decimated by Balding Critic. I wanted her to stand up for herself, like HEY, have you ever tried crying underwater?

But Balding Critic wasn't done.

THIS IS 1945 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT! YOU HAVE TO USE THE APPROPRIATE RACIAL EPITHETS!

Then Balding Critic started listing them out–for the entire store to hear. 

I was like: oh, crap. My geographical proximity to this is making my whiteness feel guilty by association.

After an agonizing moment, another member of the group spoke up, timidly: "Well, do you think someone will buy a book that has [racial epithet] on the first page? I know I wouldn't."

I was about to cheer for Timid One when Balding Critic shook her head vehemently: "NO! NO! THIS IS ABOUT HISTORICAL ACCURACY!"

Well, at least, her version of it.

Which was more like historical accurassy.

And that's when I moved camp to the far end of the store.

Dude, no wonder I gave up on graduate writing seminars. What a joke those were, all us unpublished authors sitting around slamming each other's writing. Or trying to come up with brilliant analysis of some guy's story about a dinner party where the main entree was Poop Loaf (I'm not making that up).

Now I just blog. And people send me hate mail.

Know what? It's way better. Dude, I love the Internets.

This entry was posted in SmartAssery, Societal Commentary, Writing. Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://downhillbothways.com Abraham Piper

    “YOU CAN’T FEEL YOUR TEARS IF YOU’RE UNDERWATER!”

    That critic just gave you the title for some perfect emo for free.

  • http://profile.typepad.com/teachingonmarsblogspotcom Loren C. Klein @ Teaching on Mars

    Everybody’s a critic.

    Whilst I concur that blogging is the far better method of getting your writing itch scratched, there is something special about wrestling down a big idea and making a coherent plot out of it, which you never can do with a blog.

    But I’m with you, blogging is a hoot. I just with I could get hate mail like you. My critics tend to come and (attempt to) hash it out in person. It’s just not the same as anonymous hate mail. :^(

  • http://www.bayoubelles.com Mama Belle

    Hilarious! I’m not a good enough writer to get hate mail. I just blog for fun … unconventional idea, I know … definitely not to get my “writing” out there. The last time I got praise for my writing was my second grade story on traveling in a time machine.

  • http://www.virginiaknowles.blogspot.com VirginiaKnowles

    Elizabeth, have you ever read anything by Christopher deVinck, who is Catholic? I loved The Book of Moonlight, which is a collection of some of his essays, and want to order Compelled to Write to You: Letters on Faith, Love, Service, and Life.

  • http://thewilcoxes.blogspot.com Cara

    Ahhhh, you kill me, Elizabeth. (In a good way.)

    By the way, I bought *the* issue of Mothering Magazine last week so I could read your article. What a wonderful piece! Congratulations, again. It must be crazy fun to see your writing all glossy and illustrated and everything. So excited for you.

  • Maggie Dee

    Well…I just told my kids the other day that opinions are like butts. Everyone has one and sometimes they stink!

    I gave up reading blogs for Lent. It’s good to be back. Happy Easter!

  • Alice

    If what you wrote here was the first page of a novel, I’d read it! :^) Thanks! This was wonderful and inspiring. (From one whose default drowning-sorrows mode is also to turn to a book.)

  • http://profile.typepad.com/thatguykc ThatGuyKC

    I love your visual depiction of the Balding Critic.

    My response to her may have been along the uncouth and unprofessional lines of:

    “Hey Don Quixote! How’s this for historically accurate – shut your gaping cake hole!”

    Thank you for being more socially reserved than I and am truly sorry you were ever exposed to poop loaf.

  • http://bellwhistlemoon.blogspot.com/ mary bailey

    Ha! This made me laugh. :-)

    Regarding “poop loaf”, and racial epithets, you should read “The Help” by Kathryn Stockett.

    What book *did* you pick out at the bookstore?

  • http://terrybreathinggrace.wordpress.com terry@breathing grace

    Funny post, Elizabeth. Very funny.

  • http://dawnfarias.com Dawn Farias

    Dude, no wonder I gave up on graduate writing seminars. What a joke those were, all us unpublished authors sitting around slamming each other’s writing. Or trying to come up with brilliant analysis of some guy’s story about a dinner party where the main entree was Poop Loaf (I’m not making that up).

    Ha! I minored in philosophy and also hung around a lot of coffee shops smoking cigarettes outside and talking about The World. Both scenarios were a lot like that.