The Cross and the Crucifix

In art…we are helped to remember some of the glorious things we have forgotten… –Madeline L’Engle “Walking on Water.”

The Crucifix helps me remember.

I remember the first time I entered a Catholic Church to pray I was filled with a trembling, anxious, heavy kind of dread. I had been inside Catholic churches as a tourist, a spectator. But I had never gone to a Catholic Church with the intention to pray.

I ducked into the church through the side entrance, glanced around furtively and slithered into a back pew. I felt like I was an unclean outsider, trespassing on the sacred religion of a people I didn’t understand. I had even dialed the church office, half-hoping I would hear the church was closed, visitors unwelcome.

But someone answered the phone and I stammered out a question, “Um, can a non-Catholic enter the church to pray?”

“Of course, dear,” the church secretary replied. “The church is open. Go sit down and pray. Don’t be afraid.”

How did she know I was afraid?

As I slouched in the pew, I could hardly raise my eyes. I had never allowed myself to fully gaze upon the Crucifix. I took a few deep breaths and then looked up.

It was the first time in my life I had looked upon a Crucifix with a desire to be reminded of what Christ did, to ask whether He had done it for me.

The Crucifix is at once both jarring and profound. You are forced to acknowledge the brutality of crucifixion–it is not a pleasant, polite, docile image. It is shocking. It is almost…garish. It made me ask myself: why? Why the crucifixion? Why such a brutal, seemingly needless end to life?

The only power that overcomes the reality of suffering, injustice and evil in this world is love. Only love conquers death.

The Crucifix is the tangible reminder of what Jesus had to endure for Love. And I need that reminder. Without understanding what He suffered, how can we fully appreciate what He won on our behalf?

Growing up with a faith practice that was completely stripped of any symbol or icon–I had a sort of Platonic, disembodied view of what Christ did for me. And even when I attended churches that had empty crosses in their sanctuaries, it was a very clean, tidy view of what happened to our Lord.

The Catholic Church addresses death, suffering, agony and ugliness head-on. There is no dancing around the topic, no tidying up. The Crucifix only shocks us if we’ve forgotten what Christ endured. The Crucifix is a shorthand way of reminding us: “Look! Look at Me! Look what I did for you!”

The Crucifix reminded me that what Christ accomplished didn’t stop with His death. As a child I was taught that Catholics over-emphasize the crucifixion when what is really important is not that Christ died–but that He rose.

I’ve come to realize that I need to emphasize both. I need to see His wounds and I need to celebrate His Resurrection. If I only celebrate the Resurrection without walking through Christ’s suffering, I lose a fullness of understanding. To focus exclusively on the Resurrection is like skipping to the end of the book and reading the ending. It’s like eating dessert first, without enjoying the full meal. I need the whole book. I need the full-course meal.

The Crucifix is love chasing us down, demanding that we look straight at what Love did for us. This has always been the most difficult thing for me: to believe Love. To accept love.

And then one day, a Norbertine monk insisted I take his Crucifix.

I had just gone to Confession and afterwards, he said he had something for me.

“This crucifix belonged to Mother Teresa,” he said, his voice barely more than a whisper. “My brother received it from her.”

I felt shaken to my core. “I can’t take this!” I protested. “This must be your most priceless possession!”

He shrugged, smiling gently. “The Holy Spirit told me to give it to you.”

Who argues with the Holy Spirit? Apparently, I do.

“But I’m not worthy of this! Please! I can’t! This was Mother Teresa’s!”

The monk just smiled, refusing to take it back.

And I was silenced.

This is how it has been all along–Love seeking me. Love finding me. Love initiating. Love never turning its back on me. Love using others to show me the way. Love, always love.

Here was love, again. The one Catholic I had always admired (even during my time as a virulent anti-Catholic) was Mother Teresa. I couldn’t believe that a tiny piece of her had found its way to me. I felt almost humiliated. Also, I’m not one given to signs and wonders. But what do you do when a big ol’ sign whaps you upside the head? How do you explain it?

Well, you can’t explain it. At least, I can’t. Either you accept it as coming from God or you dismiss it.

I choose to believe Love is seeking me.

_______________________________________________________

This entry was posted in Catholicism. Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://www.domesticadventure.blogspot.com Catherine

    As a life-long Protestant, I never really understood the beauty of a crucifix. There are a number of “Catholic” items and activities that I have come to really cherish. I love the idea of the Daily Office, although I’m not very good in the actual practice! I use prayer beads which has a crucifix on it. I grew up in a Protestantism that was so virulently anti-Catholic, that we were never taught about some of these lovely things that Christians have been doing for centuries. And the crucifix is a wonderful, visual reminder of Jesus’ blood sacrifice. I need to be reminded of it often.

    Catherine

  • http://www.jenniferfulwiler.com Jennifer @ Conversion Diary

    This is an absolutely beautiful, profound post. Thank you.

  • http://www.amberpeace.com Amber-Lee

    My husband and often argue about the Crucifix. I love and adore it. He feels, as we were brought up to believe, it places too much emphasis on the death and not on the resurrection. You eloquently say what I often stumble at trying to explain.

    • Jack

      In the Orthodox and Byzantine Catholic tradition, the processional Cross is two-sided.

      One face shows Christ Crucified. The other shows Christ Risen.

      These are two sides of the same thing.

      And a second-class relic of Mother Theresa! How lovely. (Second-class relics are something the saint used during his/her lifetime.)

  • http://www.mysteryandmanners.net Rachel

    Beautiful story!

  • http://bellwhistlemoon.blogspot.com/ mary bailey

    Beautiful!

  • http://www.badcatholic-eclecticreader.blogspot.com Mark Mitchell (Bad Catholic @ The Eclectic Reader)

    This is a beautiful meditation. I am going to post a link to it at LOVE IN THE RUINS. God Bless.

  • KatR

    Yeah….. I’m still working through my thinking on the crucifixion. What I had been taught left me with this:

    1) God took the wrath he felt for me and poured it instead on his Son, so
    2) Jesus came to save me from God.

    This plus all of the violence associated with the crucifixion….I don’t like to spend a lot of time thinking about it, but I guess I’ll get there when I get there.

    • http://faithandfood.morizot.net/ Scott Morizot

      You’re right. That’s an ugly and pointless story. I prefer this one.

      1. Jesus suffered everything we suffer, including the worst that the powers can do up to and including the ultimate power of death.

      2. By doing so, he took their wrath upon himself and in his Resurrection, defeated all the powers on our behalf.

      3. Jesus freed humanity from their subjection under the powers, including sin and death. In him we find freedom and life.

      Both the version you shared and the one above are rather truncated. There are works upon works written about both. But I have no interest in the God of the story you shared. I’m captivated by the God of the story above.

      • KatR

        That is a better story.

        When you refer to “the powers”, what are you talking about exactly?

    • Tammy

      Thinking that Jesus came to save you FROM God is scarry to me…I get the whole redemption concept, but in this GOd suffered more than me..He made a great sacrifice to save me.

  • http://faithandfood.morizot.net/ Scott Morizot

    In his Resurrection, Christ still bore the scars of the wounds of his crucifixion. That tells us something about his Resurrection.

    And I dare say it tells us something about the nature of our own resurrection as well …

    • http://fromthepulpitofmylife.blogspot.com/ Ruth Ann

      Catholics see the Paschal Mystery as one thing: life, death, and resurrection are ONE. And it’s all LOVE.

      • http://www.elizabethesther.com elizabeth

        Yes! All one!

  • http://somewiseguy.com ThatGuyKC

    Powerful stuff. Thank you for sharing with us.

    Catholicism is part of my family history and I remember the first time I entered one when I was 11. Such a sense of reverence an awe.

  • http://ainesahm.blogspot.com Canadian Anne

    I’m Protestant (Baptist, to be exact), and have always been drawn to crosses and even crucifixes from as far back as I can remember. I don’t own or wear a crucifix, but I do wear crosses. I’ve had accusations of “icongraphy” labelled at me, and other fellow believers, who don’t understand why I would wear that symbol. How else can I identify who I am, spiritually? It is a silent witness on my behalf. I don’t worship the item, I use it to remind myself of the horrible cost of my salvation.
    I understand your point, EE, about rushing to emphasize the Resurrection over the crucifixion. You can’t have one without the other…it’s like faith & works, as James so eloquently puts it in his epistle. The resurrection apart from the crucifixion doesn’t make sense, and is part of a greater whole. I think the typical Protestant response to crucifixes is a knee-jerk reaction, on that is deep-seated, and isn’t necessarily helpful. Personally, I like both the empty cross and the crucifix…together they tell the whole story.
    This was very good to read..thank you!

  • http://michelle-endlessstrength.blogspot.com Michelle

    This is beautiful. Thank you for writing it.

  • http://hereisthechurch.wordpress.com Allie

    An eloquent story, and a powerful reminder.

    Also, this story reminded me a bit of yours: http://evlogiaonline.com/2010/12/30/holy-innocents/

  • http://wonderfulworldofweez.blogspot.com/ Louise

    Elizabeth, this is a beautiful post. Growing up Catholic, surrounded by crucifixes at home, at church, and at school, I have always felt an odd emptiness when looking at a bare cross. I need to be reminded of what Christ did for me, and often, and the crucifix does that in a very powerful way for me.
    Thank you for sharing the story about Mother Teresa’s crucifix — Love is absolutely seeking you!

  • debbie

    after stumbling upon your blog ,as I am sure I was suppose to do ,
    this passage jumped into my heart and , I am sure, I am to pass it along to you .
    It’s Numbers 6: 24
    ”May the Lord bless you and keep you.
    May the Lord make his face to shine upon you,
    and be gracious to you.
    May the Lord lift up his countenance upon you,
    and give you peace.”
    I pray this helps you .

    I struggle everyday with cigarettes.
    I know they are taking precious minutes, hours , days ,years away
    from the ones I love most . I don’t know why it’s important for me to tell
    you this , a complete stranger, but it is.
    God works in mysterious ways….

    • http://www.elizabethesther.com elizabeth

      Thank you. And rest assured: all of us struggle with issues that take away precious minutes, hours, days away from our loved ones. Most of us are not as honest about it as you are. Admitting to the struggle is half the battle. Press on.

  • http://fromthepulpitofmylife.blogspot.com/ Ruth Ann

    I was introduced to the crucifix in my Catholic childhood. My father told me that even if I were the only person in the world, Jesus would have died on the cross just for me. I’ve always remembered that.

  • http://artsymuffin.blogspot.com Leanne

    Walking on Water is one of my all-time favorite books! I am in the midst of packing for a big move, and am now resisting my urge to rip through my already-packed boxes of books and find it for a re-read :) .

    It is, indeed, comforting to know that my Lord went through everything I have been through – and more. To me, this “qualifies” Him to bring me through everything I have gone through and will go through. Yes, it is important that He rose – but equally important that He suffered.

    Thanks for the beautiful and powerful reminder!

  • Tammy

    I grew up hearing how awful the Catholic Church was both from ex-Catholics (they did NOT turn out to be good resources about the faith) and anti Catholics. And God, in His wisdom and sense of humor brought me to the Catholic church. I love having sacred things and places and actions. I get SO frustrated as a Catholic when people get in my grill and throw question after question at me with a snarky sarcasm and never let me answer as if the question answered itself….and each question HAS an answer.

    I recently heard a woman tell a story…she had always seen a gesture Catholics make when the Gospel is read and she snarkily asked “what is that thing you do waving your hands in the air?”…the person she posed the question lovingly said “we make the cross on our foreheads, our mouth and our chest and say ‘Lord, may your words be on my mind, on my lips and in my heart’ ” The lady who asked the question said she couldnt even speak as she thought it was such a beautiful thing that she had actually mocked and looked down on for so long.

    I recently had a crucifix given to me in a setting that was very powerful …no sooner was it in my hand then the Holy Spirit said “give this to Teresa”…well there you go!!

    • http://www.elizabethesther.com elizabeth

      I love the gesture we make on our foreheads, lips and heart just before the Gospel is read. It is such a beautiful sign of reverence for the Gospel. We also stand to hear the reading of the Gospel. Yes, each question has an answer. Sometimes we just have to stop and listen.

  • http://mecerone.blogspot.com Mary Beth

    Wow. Beautiful.

  • http://recoveringpessimist.blogspot.com Jennifer

    Thank you, Elizabeth.

  • http://seekingsteward.blogspot.com/ Ashley

    Elizabeth, this is a beautiful post. I admire the vulnerability you expose in your writing. There’s a sincerity in you that speaks volumes!

  • http://heldts.blogspot.com Brianna

    This is so incredibly beautiful. Thank you.

  • http://grace-filled.net jen

    empty catholic churches are seriously the best places to pray. i’ve never been in one and not felt that i was in a sacred space.

    bonus: i light candles for people when i’m there.

  • Mark S.

    Elizabeth, so beautiful. You say so clearly what I feel. Once, when struggling with a certain sin, my confessor suggested that I get a crucifix intended to hung on the wall at home but instead, hold it while sitting and looking at it and meditating. It was the most profoundly moving experience I had had in trying to overcome my sin and it has remained so. in fact, I find myself needing to hold that crucifix while praying sometimes; the feel of it in my hands is a real tactile reminder that God loves me beyond my understanding. Thank you for your generous witness and helping me in turn witness that God is love.

  • http://www.powerofamoment.com Susan

    Elizabeth,
    That is one of the most beautiful posts I have ever read…thank you for sharing your heart in such a profound way. He loves you so much!
    Blessings,
    Susan

  • Lindsey Wilson

    WOW.

  • Katharine

    This was exactly what I needed this morning. Thank you for a beautiful post!

  • Sharon O

    Beautiful.
    I am not catholic and I do not hold to that teaching but I do love the same God and the same ‘Holy Spirit’ ministers to us all. I can worship in a catholic church as well as a ‘small’ hometown pentecostal church. We all serve the same God. The crucifix is a reminder of a very loving thing that our Lord did. Remember he struggled. In the garden he asked ‘can it be removed, do I have to …??’ and in the end HE knew the purpose of LOVE was to be extended to the fullest so that we can have LIFE forever.
    The cross … Oh the cross. The Old Rugged Cross…on a hill faraway…I will always remember and love the song. Keep pressing into God and HE will meet you just as He did for me. The crucifix is beautiful as a simple symbol of LOVE.
    I will pray for you. Instead of unsubscribing to your ‘blog’ I will pray since I couldn’t figure out how to Unsubscribe. I will pray for your heart your spirit and your journey. God will meet you and heal your heart just keep pressing in to Him.

  • Wendy

    Fantastic blog post. I’ve never looked at the crucifix from this perspective. The post helped me understand why some prefer the crucifix.

    I’ve always felt that an empty cross was a better Christian symbol, but now I see why some feel otherwise.

    Thanks for helping me see the other side of the coin.

  • http://amywelborn.wordpress.com Amy

    I was thinking about this last Friday night at the Stations of the Cross – how Christianity – and specifically Catholicism/Orthodoxy – in its symbols and the spirituality which those symbols evoke – is the only place in our culture in which death and all of its attendant questions are regularly and directly confronted.

    Take the crucifixes away…and what do you have?

    A culture that can ignore death, suffering and their meaning (which then spills over to the meaning of life itself) – even more than it already does..

  • http://thechuppies.blogspot.com/ Kara

    I loved this section from your post:
    “This is how it has been all along–Love seeking me. Love finding me. Love initiating. Love never turning its back on me.”

    Reminded me of C.S. Lewis’ poem:
    “No Beauty We Could Desire”

    Yes, you are always everywhere. But I,
    Hunting in such immeasurable forests,
    Could never bring the noble Hart to bay.

    The scent was too perplexing for my hounds;
    Nowhere sometimes, then again everywhere.
    Other scents, too, seemed to them almost the same.

    Therefore I turned my back on the unapproachable
    Stars and horizons and all musical sounds,
    Poetry itself, and the winding stair of thought.

    Leaving the forests where you are pursued in vain
    –Often a mere gleam–I turned instead
    To the appointed place where you pursue.

    Not in Nature, not even in Man, but in one
    Particular Man, with a date, so tall, weighing
    So much, talking Aramaic, having learned a trade;

    Not in all food, not in all bread and wine
    (Not, I mean, as my littleness requires)
    But this wine, this bread…no beauty we could desire.
    ~C.S. Lewis

  • http://remnantofremnant.blogspot.com priest’s wife

    When we (5 kids and mom and dad) converted- I was 12- the crucifix was one of the aspects of the Church we were attracted to

    One piece of advice to no one in particular- always remind children of the resurrection- when doing the Stations of the Cross with your kids, you might add a station so that they are reminded that the story doesn’t end with the crucifixion

  • http://www.seeprestonblog.com Preston Yancey

    “Who argues with the Holy Spirit? Apparently, I do.”

    You me and everyone we know, Elizabeth.

    When I was younger and precocious, I remember one Sunday at a church where my father was a pastor and my Sunday School teacher informed us that the problem with Catholics was that “their Jesus never came down from the cross.” I repeated this definition to my parents, who were mortified, and later sat down with the Sunday School teacher and explained to her very gently the difference between the crucifix and the cross, the necessity for both, and theology of love too big to say out loud, like the true name of God.

    That may be one of my favorite memories of my very Southern Baptist parents.

  • Donna

    Love this post!

    And I love that you are choosing to believe… to turn towards instead of away from.

    I’ve only met practicing Catholics in the last 3 years, and have been fascinated to learn how very alike we are in our beliefs :)

  • http://www.wholeheartedcatholic.com Leslie McCaddon

    Elizabeth,
    I just read this post for the 3rd time. Thank you so much for sharing this. One of those posts I keep email to everyone.
    Leslie

  • Lacinda

    Very cool story! Mother Theresa has been such an inspiration to me.

  • Hannah

    That the crucifix is such a symbol is even more extraordinary in the context of the 1st century AD. The cross was not only a horrible method of execution, but one reserved for the lowest classes of society, for those with no rights – slaves, pirates, enemies of the state. There were many religions in ancient Rome where a sole divine figure offered some kind of transcendence of death, but these figures were often elevated and heroic – that Christianity should have a saviour that was not only executed, but executed in such a degrading way, was incomprehensible to many in antiquity. I must confess that I’m an agnostic, but I have to admit that this is something I find compelling. If you were going to make up a saviour in the 1st century AD, you wouldn’t have him die like this – it wouldn’t make sense, it wouldn’t make him seem glorious or divine, it wouldn’t attract people…and yet, it did.

  • http://frombitterwaterstosweet.blogspot.com/ Mara

    Very beautiful.

  • http://biblicalwrestling.wordpress.com/ Andrea

    Growing up in a Baptist church, I was told we didn’t need crucifixes because they didn’t show Jesus overcoming death. We didn’t need to see him suffering; we needed the empty cross to be a reminder of his resurrection. But I too have come to appreciate the crucifix. My Catholic college had one hanging in every room. As I looked at the crucifix daily, I was reminded of the suffering I so often forget. Yes, we must remember the glory and hope of the resurrection, but we must remember the pain of the cross, as well. The crucifix helps me believe that because Jesus suffered so much, he can enter into my own suffering and help ease the burden.

  • http://heartsoulexchange.blogspot.com/ Heart and Soul

    Love reading your thoughts Elizabeth….beautifully articulated….especially the parallels of the two sides.

  • Pat

    All I can say is that I love this. Love it.

  • http://justmomsmusings.blogspot.com Just Mom

    Words cannot even describe how much I truly love this post. Beautifully said.

  • Pingback: THE SATURDAY EVENING BLOG POST, vol. 3, issue 3 | Elizabeth Esther