A necessary anger

“Great emotions are especially powerful teachers. Even anger and rage are great teachers, if we listen to them. They have the capacity to blind you, but also the power to open you up, and bring you profound conversion, humility and honesty. People who are too nice and never suffer or reveal their negative emotions, usually do not know very much about themselves…the feminist movement has rightly recognized that many women have to be led into a necessary anger.
Richard Rohr, “Hope Against Darkness” (pg. 99,100)

Not only are women supposed to suffer public, blatant sexist humor at the hands of our Christian brothers, we are also not allowed to be angry about it. Indeed, where is our sense of humor? Can’t we “overly sensitive” women take a joke?

Getting angry is a cardinal sin–for a woman.

Women in the church, you see, are expected to endure all manner of crude jokes, putdowns, mockery, being told to shut up, to keep quiet, to not get our “panties in a knot,” to not be so easily offended.

And we’re supposed to endure all this without ever once getting angry.

Because as soon as we get angry, well, we’ve crossed a line. We’ve invalidated our arguments. We’ve become “emotional” and–my personal favorite–unable to “think logically.”

Ironically, the first thing I learned in therapy was the necessity of anger. I can’t tell you how many therapy sessions started with me saying: “Well, this probably doesn’t qualify as abuse but…..” and then go on to describe a horrifyingly abusive experience.

When my therapist asked me if I was angry about what happened, I’d say: “Oh, no! I’ve forgiven and moved on!”

Because that’s what nice, Christian women do, right? We don’t get angry! We forgive! We play nice! We move on!

The problem, of course, was that by never allowing myself to feel anger about what happened, I missed a crucial, vital step in the mourning/recovery process. By rushing to Forgive-And-Move-On!, I repressed the negative emotions without transforming them.

The hardest lesson I’ve had to learn in the past 9 years is that if I don’t transform my pain, I will transmit it.

When I first went to therapy, I couldn’t understand why I kept having these unpredictable outbursts of anger. I thought I needed to learn how to better control my temper. It wasn’t until I was willing to look at what was causing the anger that I was able to truly move forward.

Allowing myself to feel angry about legitimate injustice was a necessary step toward epiphany. By circumventing necessary emotions, I’d cheated myself of fully understanding and living my spiritual journey.

Furthermore, by stuffing down the negative emotions, I was actually guaranteeing they’d explode at a different time in a completely unpredictable way.

In other words, you can’t take detours around negative emotions without paying the price later on. Those emotions are there for a reason. The anger is there to teach you something. It’s your job to find out the lesson hiding behind the anger.

I didn’t want to be angry. But I needed to be angry.

Anger, I learned, is a proper and God-given response to injustice. When you are being unfairly treated, abused or witness the unfair treatment and abuse of others–you are supposed to get angry.

It is good to be offended by what is offensive.

If we are NOT angered by injustice, if we are NOT offended by what is offensive, then the only transformation we can hope for is a superficial one.

So, yes. I am angered by injustice and the ongoing, sexist treatment of women in the church. I am grieved that young men in the church are adopting and continuing these attitudes.

I am a woman. And I am angry.

This entry was posted in Her Royal Mommy-Ness, Societal Commentary. Bookmark the permalink.
  • lauren

    AMEN.

  • Ali

    Oh I loved this! Write a book based on this. I know 100 people just in my own network who need to hear this message. Elizabeth, this was a terrific post! I send you very best autumnal wishes from Switzerland. Alison

  • Hippie Gramma

    The blatant misogyny and insistence on relegating women to second-class status in the name of God is what is driving me away from the church.  No matter how inspiring the music, how educational the programs, how supportive the community, if women are not treated as equal citizens my heart and conscience are just no longer able to get past that.

    Have I come to the point in my life where the pain of rejection — and that is what it is when you are automatically judged as lesser — because of my gender just too much?  Even the evil secular (modern) world has eradicated most official gender discrimination.  My faith is the ONLY PLACE in life where I am expected to tolerate (with a smile) sanctioned rejection and discrimination. How ironic.  And sickening. And sad.

  • http://twitter.com/rachelisasmith Rachel Newsome Smith

    the thing that made me the most sad was all the women being like ” i am a woman(a BAD girl) and I wasn’t offended by this!” which somehow translates into “no *cool* girl should be offended by this,” or that “so any other woman who is offended by this is toooooo sensitive.” That always rubs me the wrong way. Do we need to be “cool girls” about things that are hurtful so that men will like us even more? ugh

    I also do not understand all the apologists on that particular post (who DIDN”T EVEN WRITE IT) that felt the need to go through and correct anyone who was offended. In my heart i was screaming “THIS?! THIS is the issue that you feel the need to defend to heartily at the expense of the hearts of your brothers and sisters.”

    I know it offends the hell out of some men to hear that they have privilege, but they do, and until they start helping us out instead of tearing us down for being angry or making insensitive comments and posts and expecting us to lighten up, they are complicit.

    Thank you for your anger, EE. You are heard and appreciated by this angry, emotional feminist. :-)

  • Strphanie Mumpower

    Heck YA!!!!

  • Elizabeth

    Yes, this is exactly what I thought, too!  Because while that post was demeaning to all women, “good” and “bad” alike, the commenters missed the point that the “good girls” had reason be to troubled, that it said that, no matter what our mothers and fathers taught us, you’ll never win by playing by the rules.  Playing by the rules makes you boring, and boring = not attractive. 

    I’ve joked for years that when I find a man whose mother hates me, he’ll be the on who wants to marry me.  Nothing turns a man off any faster than a ringing endorsement from his family!  So, the things in that post are true.  Let’s call them what they are and have a conversation, rather than hiding behind humor and satire.

  • Lara

    I love you.

  • Jen

    Thank you SO much for taking on this issue.  I wholeheartedly agree and support your perspective on the particular SCL post, and the issue more generally.  I am so very, very tired of the “lighten up”, “take a joke” attitude from men.  If they had to endure even a fraction of the abuse and disrespect that women have to endure….ugh.  Thank you, EE.

  • http://www.moonchild11.wordpress.com Sarah Moon

    I love this :)  

  • http://profiles.google.com/lucyvaliant Nicole Hallford

    Oh my goodness, this is SO true and SO well said! You’re amazing!!

  • Elizabeth McClintic

    Richard Rohr makes me angry. It seems to me that he pats us on our soft little heads.

    “the greatest in the kingdom are not the ministers but the saints.”

    Women are oft times their own worse enemy, especially when they deny who they are in the feminine sense and allow themselves to be used as objects. We are indeed equal, but not the same.

  • http://www.diannaeanderson.net Dianna

    THANK YOU.

    I cannot tell you how many times I have been told that I’m “too angry and irrational,” especially during moments when I’m behaving in a reasonably calm and restrained manner. And for many men (because it’s almost always men telling me about *my* anger), simply disagreeing in an emphatic manner is perceived as “out of control angry.” For example, in one discussion, a guy said something extremely offensive that was tantamount to white washing abuse. I knew I could not respond to him without yelling, so I packed up my stuff, quietly explained that I did not think I could respond to what he said in a calm, collected manner, so “I am going to remove myself from the situation.” And I did – I stood up and walked out of the public place where we were.

    When he rehashes the story two months later, I evidently screeched at him and bolted. Yeah.

    So I’ve given up on trying to cater to the people who think I shouldn’t be ‘angry’ or that my emotional appeal clouds my ‘rational’ side, as though the two are in opposition to each other. Thanks for validating that stance.

  • http://hippiehousewife.blogspot.com Cynthia @ The Hippie Housewife

    I’ve had similar thoughts weighing heavily on my mind since a recent conversation with a friend. She was describing the awful way her husband treats her, but condemning her own anger that arose from the mistreatment. She should bear the mistreatment in a more godly manner, she said, becoming more holy rather than more angry.  No!  That anger is there for a reason! But all she could see were her own “shortcomings” that the anger must surely represent.

    Like physical pain, anger serves a good and useful purpose. It should not be ignored anymore than we would ignore the sensation of “HOT! MOVE HAND!” when touching a hot stove.

  • KatR

    I’ve decided that there is only one word for men in the church who decide to “challenge the thinking” of other men in the chuch by ridiculing and demeaning women.

    Cowardly.

    Well, sorry, two words.

    Weak would be the other one.

  • ARM

    You’d like Aristotle’s discussion of anger in the Ethics.  For him, every virtue is a mean between two extremes – the right amount of some emotion or action – whereas too much or too little are both vices.  So getting angry too much is a vice, but so is getting angry too little; the virtue is to get angry at the right things, in the right way, etc.  He says that’s what the virtue of gentleness actually is; never getting angry is being apathetic, not gentle.

  • http://stitchinguptheseams.wordpress.com/ Stitching Seams

    Thank you for this! I was part of a discussion on Facebook not long ago in which I and another woman who has suffered sexual assault (hers was rape, mine was not) were engaging men about the topic of sexual violence and moral responsibility. At one point, a man who had thusfar been very level-headed and open-minded in the conversation defined the content of my friend’s argument as a non-stop tirade against someone who had seemed to indicate that he thought that the Old Testament economy of dealing with rapists AND their victims ought to be upheld in Christianity today. I tried to explain to him that my friend and I had first-hand experienced the kind of commentary about assault that was being perpetuated and it was neither fair, right, nor possible for us to discuss it without becoming angry…he didn’t seem to agree.

  • http://www.krwordgazer.blogspot.com Kristen

    Well said, Elizabeth.  You know what else burns me?  When a man speaks emphatically and with conviction about something, he is “forthright” or “firm” or “courageous.”  When a woman does the same, she is “strident,” or “bitter” or even “bitchy.”

    It’s about time we women were allowed to use our words.  That’s why I love the title to your blog.

    Kristen (aka KR Wordgazer)

  • Tara S

    I like my friends, the saints.  They got mad sometimes. So did Jesus Himself!  Throwing tables around, chasing people out of the Temple. Seriously, why couldn’t He just lighten up? Those market people didn’t mean any harm!  What an overly sensitive, emotional basketcase He was.  

    Appropriate anger is not a bad thing, and men of good character aren’t usually so frightened by emotions that they’ll dismiss a person’s view entirely as a means to run away and hide.  In my experience, well-meaning people can occasionally hurt people by accident, and when they do, they say “Oh I’m sorry – my mistake,” not “Lighten up, nerd/feeble woman/etc.”  I hope that is what will happen in the case of the original “joke” post, but as for all the “Lighten up” responses thus far from other people (I’m thinking in particular of Snarky McSnarkpants who responded with a caustic sneer to nearly each comment in your last post on the subject) honestly I’m kind of disappointed.  

    Come on, dudes!  We’re not in ur computerz, harshing ur buzz.  We’re responding to how we are depicted in public.  We don’t like it. That is our prerogative.  I don’t understand how our right to have feelings about this is even at issue.

  • Renee

    So true, EE. Thank you for writing this!! It took me a long time to realize that anger is a necessary step in the healing process.

  • Susan

    <3

    Too often I've been told that I needed to let go of something before I got to work it through. Thanks, gf.

  • Anonymous

    I think that’s the biggest bunch of baloney ever! When people say you need to “let it go” before you work through something, they’re usually just saying it because it would make it easier for THEM.

  • Lucie

    Elizabeth, I apologize if this question has already been answered and I simply did not see it, but I was curious as to whether you had contacted Jon Acuff personally about your reaction to his post?

  • Anonymous

    Yep. Posted on his FB wall. No response.

  • Anonymous

    Also multiple tweets. No response.

  • D

    Thank you for writing this. It needs to be heard!

  • http://thehomespunlife.com Sisterlisa

    I didn’t see your comment on his FB page. Did he delete it?

  • KatR

    You know, that’s interesting. Elizabeth left a comment, and I left a comment, and I was expecting a deluge of “why are you so SENSITIVE” replies, and I didn’t hear a peep.

    I wonder if it was deleted?

  • chick

    It’s just simply clear that some men don’t believe the part about “neither Jew nor Gentile, neither male nor female”…  For them, someone’s femaleness will always make them less.  It’s a hugely anti-Christian attitude, but one that means more to them than they are willing to give up.

    And lest I be dismissed as some shrill feminist harpie, I’m a pro-life SAHM of 3, soon to be 4, proud to be my husband’s friend and partner, to cook his meals, and to do whatever I can to make his life easier.  He makes it easy for me to WANT to do these things for him, because he genuinely sees and treats me as his equal.

  • http://twitter.com/rachelisasmith Rachel Newsome Smith

    well for me though, part of my problem was that it was men deciding what was “good” or “bad,” and all of that seemed so arbitrary. Also, so many of those things do not remind me of my own friends with a past (including myself) they reminded me more of high school girls. I don’t like being treated like a little girl.

    If the post was “about how men think” why was the huge list of QUALITIES ABOUT WOMEN necessary? geesh

  • Valerie

    I wish I could remember where I read it (here?) but a therapist or a psychologist said that an appropriate remark to make in response to someone telling you that you are too emotional or too angry is, “Well, what is an appropriate level of emotion? How much emotion is the right amount? And who gets to decide on the level?” said in a really calm manner. It should make people stop and think.

    I remember someone telling me once I was too emotional about something and I told my sweet brother about it. He replied, “That kind of remark is intended to shut someone down and is completely inappropriate”. And he doesn’t know the Lord. Love it.

    Valerie

  • Handsfull

    The thing that gets me is that the original post is about how men think.  It needs to be re-titled.  Men don’t think like that, boys do.  Age doesn’t make you a man, maturity does.  Nobody with any maturity would think like that, therefore this is obviously a post about immature boys. :)

  • Alaina

    This really spoke to the deepest parts of my soul. I particularly love the “Allowing myself to feel angry about legitimate injustice was a necessary step toward epiphany”. This is how I have been feeling for quite some time, but unable to succinctly and accurately say it well. Thank you.

  • http://www.JanetOberholtzer.com Janet Oberholtzer

    After a major accident, I dealt with an emotional and spiritual hurricane as I tried to adjust to living with pain, limitations and a deformed leg. One of the best pieces of advice my counselor gave me was… “Feelings aren’t right or wrong, they simply are. It’s what we do with them that matters.”

    Only by allowing myself to be anger at and disappointed with God and the situation did I finally begin to heal. Many of my christian friends were not comfortable with me being honest about my feelings. They would have preferred that I stuff my feelings of anger and disappointment and instead shout “hallelujah, praise God” for surviving the accident. “After all, I had a lot to be thankful for.”

    While it’s not identical, I see this situation as being somewhat similar. Jon and John want us to know they meant well, they are just ‘honestly’ looking at the “foolishness of men.” They would prefer we shout “praise God, they dealing with their own issue” instead of hearing us as we express our feelings of anger and disappointment. “After all, we have a lot to be thankful for.”

  • joanie

    thank you, EE! Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!

  • Anonymous

    If it helps at all…and yeah, this isn’t nice….but I’ve always thought that particular website was idiotic.  Clueless, demeaning, and beneath me, even.  :)   Now?  Those thoughts have been confirmed.  :)

    Well said, EE. I’m proud of you.

  • Tammy

    EE, 

        I completely agree with what you say about anger but I cannot (despite reading it 3 times) understand how the quote you posted says what you seem to think it says. It sounds to me like he is saying that “necessary anger” is justified. 

      Back on topic though…being really angry is a luxury I have not had in life because my parents were angry and my spouse is a very angry person. I am, it seems by default, the peacemaker. 

      Having a chance to really express anger is a validating experience. When I was in Hospital Chaplaincy training, I became incensed over a group dynamic that I found insufferable. My Supervisor looked at me and said “you are really angry”   “no Im not”  ”yes you are” “yes I am, and Im gonna tell you why (insert completely appropriate rant)”. 

      My husbands constant anger has caused such destruction in my life and stolen from me the right to be angry when Im justified. Im getting angry just thinking of it. 

      

  • Janet

    I think the old saying about deep feeling, “the way out is through”, whether it be regarding anger, grief, what have you, is really true…we need to feel and experience our anger before we can move through it – when Christian women are told to get past their anger without doing this, this is really not in their best interests or respectful to them -

  • http://turquoisegates.blogspot.com Genevieve Thul@Turquoise Gates

    Not only was I out of touch with my anger, I had forgotten how to cry, ask for a need assertively, make demands when necessary, or even name my own abusive history. It wasn’t until months into therapy that I began to call a spade a spade, and for the first time in many years, felt those hot tears of anger flooding down my cheeks. My children and husband have benefited immensely through my emancipation and epiphany, although it was bought at a high price (lots of meds and a couple stays inpatient). I no longer erupt at trivial incidents with my children, and my husband can finally say that he has a wife “happily settled in her home with children.” Until recently, I was a disgruntled, suppressed, easily irritable wife and mother. If only our Christian brothers understood that by validating and allowing true womanhood in their (OUR!) communities, they would be surrounded by sisters able and willing to work alongside in furthering the Gospel.

  • Katrina

    i really that comeback..i’ll def be remembering that!

  • Sabahmom

    Once again your blog touches on something I’m dealing with. Heard some of the same words from my therapist yesterday regarding anger. OK, so it was MY apparent anger. Who KNEW I was angry? (other than my kids and my husband, I mean) “The lesson hiding behind the anger”… I’ve got nothing profound to say about any of that right now because it all feels tangled up and confusing. But your post was another nudge to keep moving in that direction.

  • Falfie4

    In psychology we are taught that anger is a secondary emotion.  Meaning, when we are angry it is usually because we feel unsafe, or are grieved over something.  I think it is worthwhile to consider that our anger may be because when our brothers make demeaning comments, they are failing to protect us and honor us as they are supposed to.  This makes us vulnerable, not because we are weak, but because they have been charged with the task of treating us with honor.  So, my hope is that when we express and work through our anger (as we should!), that we are able to convey the deeper message about what impact their actions have on us.  Because, once we can get to that deeper level and work through those emotions, the anger dissipates and transformation is possible.    

  • Anonymous

    LOVED THIS! YES YES YES.

  • http://twitter.com/suehill3k Susan Hill

    Wow. A-men. (pardon the pun) I’m withya-hon! 

    “…if I don’t transform my pain, I will transmit it.

    Love.that.statement. 

    I think a woman who is truly, righteously angry…can be a very unsettling for those who don’t know what they believe. We aren’t afraid and we won’t back down. You go, girl…er, woman. ;)

  • http://www.emergingmummy.com Sarah@EmergingMummy

    Amen, darling. Amen.

  • Claire

    Love it!  Forgiveness has its place (especially when the anger is only punishing the victim), but so does anger.  My pro-choice mother has told me patronizingly that I need to let go of my anger about abortion.  I don’t think so!  It is very appropriate to be outraged at the millions of babies who have been victimized by this barbaric legal act.

  • http://ontoberlin.blogspot.com Hannah M

     I love this post, EE! It ties in with what I have been writing about this week and I’m going to do a linkpost with all the other recent posts I’ve spotted that touch on the subject. Will add yours in! :)