Tears of despair & tears of Thanksgiving

“Get down on your knees and repent,” my grandmother said. Her voice was quiet, cold and fully controlled. Nobody defied her.

And so, I knelt.

“Say the prayer, admit that your life is a failure and a mess.”

I said the prayer.

“You didn’t say it like you meant it,” she said. “You’re going to say this prayer until you’re fully contrite.”

Shame, like a knife, pierced my stomach. I was trembling. I glanced over at my husband–he wouldn’t look at me. We’d been called into this meeting because someone had reported to my grandmother that I was “rebellious” and “unsubmissive.” I had committed the unpardonable sin of asking questions about why my cousin was being beaten by her father, a pastor in our church.

As the grand-daughter of our church’s founder, my questions were a threat to their ministry. I had to be stopped.

I knew what was required of me: a full, complete breaking. Total surrender. She wanted to see me cry.

But I had trained myself not to cry in front of her. Crying was a sign of weakness, of surrender and I didn’t want to give my grandmother the satisfaction of seeing me cry. Through a series of these meetings, she had already achieved her goal of breaking me down psychologically.

Every day I was battling suicidal thoughts. I was cutting myself. I had asked God to kill me so I wouldn’t have to live the rest of my life in this godforsaken cult.

But I did, in fact, cry that day. I wept on my knees until my grandmother was satisfied. She didn’t know that I was really weeping for the long, miserable life that stretched ahead of me, for the dreams I would never fulfill, for the children I would bear and bring into this misery, for the stupidity of ever hoping I’d be free…..

Something changed after that day. I lost hope. I resigned myself. I stopped fighting. I often wept tears of despair.

It’s been thirteen years since that day and I’ve been free for almost 9 years. I still marvel at this freedom, this precious, precious freedom.

The tears I cry now are tears of freedom and gratitude. The first Thanksgiving I celebrated after leaving the cult, I gave thanks for freedom.

Sometimes I still weep for what was lost. My husband asked me recently if I would ever want to reconnect with my grandparents. I said no. My grandparents set out to break me. They were successful and I very nearly paid for it with my life.

But I will weep for them and for the lives they destroyed. I will weep for their souls.

I will weep with thanksgiving because it is the kindness of God that leads to repentance.

This Thanksgiving, I will weep tears of gratitude because I am free.

And I will never, ever take this freedom for granted.

This entry was posted in Friday Gratitude Lists, Fundie Hierarchies, RecoveringFundamentalist. Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://somuchshoutingsomuchlaughter.com/ suzannah {ShoutLaughLove}

    oh elizabeth. joining you in thanksgiving for freedom and love and re-creation. xo

  • https://creativecommons.net/prosario2000/identity Pedro M. Rosario Barbosa

    This post deeply moved me.  Thank you for sharing this.  I thank God for many blessings, and one of them is you, your thoughts, your heart and your words.  God bless you always. :-)

  • Anonymous

    I thank God that He led you out of that darkness and through the tunnel into the light. You are a truly amazing person and I am blessed by your writing and your witness. I thank Him for YOU!

  • Marie

    Words fail me. . .I’m so thankful that you are free and that you have come to know a gentle, compassionate God.  Happy Thanksgiving, Elizabeth!

  • Joy

    I weep with you.

  • Kelly

    The tears surface reading this, and I take a deep breath. There’s wonder here I’ve only begun to understand.

    Happy Thanksgiving, friend.

  • Handsfull

    It’s not only the good who can see the strength in us, the bad can too.  They know it’s a threat to them, so they think they must destroy the strength we have, before we use our strength to destroy them.  Your grandmother was right – you are strong, and what you have in you is a danger to her and her kind.  And now you are using that strength in the right way… to speak for the voiceless, to expose wrong-doing, to give joy and hope.  And to sing, and laugh and shout and live free!
    God bless you, Elizabeth!

  • http://kansasbob.com Kansas Bob

    I started to cry as I read your story and was glad that my tears of horror and sadness turned into ones of gladness. I join you in giving thanks for our freedom in Jesus.

  • http://ifmeadowsspeak.blogspot.com/ tammy@if meadows speak

    I’m so very glad you are free. I’ve seen religion used for man, but He didn’t come for that. He came to loose the captives.

  • Martha

    “it is the kindness of God that leads to repentance.” well said. I’m thankful you’re free too.

  • http://www.downtoearthwomen.blogspot.com Tracey

    (((hugs)))

    Thank you for sharing that. 

  • Sam

    I am so very thankful you are free, Elizabeth. I am so sorry that your grandmother caused you such pain. I would love to transport you to my grandma’s front porch for coffee and pound cake and to talk about the world. 

  • Falfie4

    I really appreciate your raw honesty in your feelings about your life in the cult.  I, too, spent much of my childhood and young adulthood asking God to kill me to spare me from the misery that was my life.  It’s such a desperate place to be.  And, I too cry tears of joy for redemption and healing.  Thank God for his faithfulness!

    I would be interested in hearing sometime how you came to leave the cult, if you haven’t already shared this.  Having spent many years in a cult myself, I know the feeling that life outside this small group is impossible.  It took some drastic circumstances to change my perspective, so I was wondering what changed for you?

  • Valerie

    So thankful for you too. I love the idea of Thanksgiving. I wish we Aussies celebrated this holiday too!

    I was thinking how amazing it is your marriage survived, too. You must have had to extend a lot of forgiveness to one another.

    I hope you are able to share the whole story someday, if and when it is right.

    Valerie

  • http://faithandfood.morizot.net/ Scott Morizot

    Peace.

    Lots of half-formed thoughts, experiences, and anecdotes came to mind as I read. But I think peace captures the essence of anything I might say.

  • Anonymous

    Good question, Falfie. I think I”ll write about this soon!

  • Poetry_4_me

    Thank you so much for sharing your experience.  Like everyone else, I was moved to tears as I read.  I’m so glad you are free.  I am so, so, so grateful that you write this blog…because now I know I’m not the “only one”.  It has provided me with a hope I thought I didn’t have.  God Bless, and Happy Thanksgiving.

  • Maggie

    I don’t really think I “got” what you meant by growing up in a cult until I read the sentence “I glanced up at my husband”.  What?!  That stopped me in my tracks.  I had to re-read it to make sure I read that right.  I thought they humiliated you while a child (beyond horrible) but I had no idea it was still going on while you were a grown, married woman.  I guess in my mind the whole time while I read cult in previous posts, I was thinking “ultra conservative” and not making the connection.   Wow…you are one strong person.   And I’m so glad you’re free.

  • http://www.stephindialogue.com Stephanie S. Smith

    Freedom is so sweet. Thanks for writing.

  • http://www.stephindialogue.com Stephanie S. Smith

    Freedom is so sweet. Thanks for writing.

  • Lucie

    Yep, that is RELIGION – not Christianity.  At least not in that spirit.

  • Lucie

    Your grandmother could not have been a happy woman…sounds to me like she was in bondage herself.  I wondered if your parents are in contact at all with your grandparents?  It sounded as if you’ve had no contact with them at all for nearly a decade?

  • Nancy

    Thanks, EE.  I was going to ask the same question (about how you left), and also how your husband left too.  It’s always interesting and miraculous to see how a married couple can come to such a difficult time of change and stay united.  I am giving thanks for your escape and the way you’ve continued to grow.

  • Steph

    I had the same reaction. Stumbled over the same section and started reading again from the beginning. I knew from what EE had written it was an abusive system, but I had no idea the level of control it could reach… I’m starting to get it. Thanks for putting your story out there, EE.

  • http://www.emergingmummy.com Sarah@EmergingMummy

    Unreal, absolutely unreal. I am thankful to my bones for you and your freedom song, too, EE.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Tammy-Dykes-Ruiz/1314651234 Tammy Dykes Ruiz

    I was also taken aback by realizing your husband was there and they convinced him it wasnt his place to rescue you from their oppression. Has he been able to forgive himself for not rescuing you sooner?  Like someone else said, Im amazed and glad you two are still togther. 

    I only had to escape one oppressive parent and it was hard enough, I cant imagine having to get away from a whole system of entrapment.

    You go girl !

  • HPT

    Thank you for your honesty. I received Not Alone from Amazon yesterday. Thanks for the recommendation and your participation. I have paused after the second essay so that my husband can read it. Praying he gets it, that I get over it, and that we can ALL live happily ever after. ;)

  • Claire

    I’m so sorry you had to endure this abuse, but glad that you ultimately escaped and have not let it keep you from a relationship with God.

  • Anonymous

    It’s chilling to read these words. I am so thankful you are free and doing something so redemptive with said freedom. Not only for yourself but countless others. I love your courage and humility through it all amd above all am thankful for your understanding of True Love.

  • River

    My daughters and I love your writing, keep going. We found as we discussed your post that none of us quite knew what “beating” meant. Nor could we figure out your husbands role or lack thereof in intervening with grandma.