How leaving church helped me become more human

I left regular church attendance a year ago.

At the time, it seemed like such a big decision. Regular church attendance was ingrained in me more deeply than any other habit. If it’s Sunday, I’m in church. It never even felt difficult to keep that habit. It was just….what was done.

In the 9 years since leaving the cult, I never stopped regular church attendance. I kept going. I kept searching. I kept believing that God was found in meetings. In the odd dissonance of how evangelicals interpret Scripture, I fully believed that God was not in a building made with hands–but He wanted me to go to a man-made building every Sunday anyway.

There’s a good deal of scary mythology that makes the rounds when you stop attending church. People tell stories of the weird fates that befall them after leaving church. They get in a freak car accident. Somebody dies. They lose a job. They start drinking heavily.

It’s the same sort of mythology that’s applied to Bible reading. My grandfather used to say that the Bible would keep you from sin or sin would keep you from the Bible. It was always either/or. If you quit reading your Bible, some disaster was bound to happen. If you were struggling with anything from a headache to mild depression, the first question you were asked was: “Are you reading your Bible regularly?”

It’s an ironic thing, really. Christians eschew superstition, but they can be pretty superstitious about what happens after you stop regular Bible reading and regular church attendance.

The only disaster that has befallen me in this past year is that I’ve become more human.

Less fearful. More loving.

Less worried about what anyone at church thinks of me. When you attend church every Sunday, there’s this keeping up of appearances that goes on. You know, you have to dress up. Look “Christian” and all that.

I’ve become almost reckless about my reputation. I could care less what people say about me. I’ve stopped worrying if everyone likes me.

I stopped going to church and started sleeping better at night. I exercised more. I made soup.

And it’s odd because when you’re outside of church for awhile and then you go back for some major holiday (like, say Christmas Eve), you have this very strange feeling–an almost out-of-body experience. Being there–in church–you remember the Old You that used to sit there and you’re shocked to discover how much the Present You is different.

For one thing, I forgot how loooooooong sermons are. Damn. Seriously? 45 minutes of preaching? What?! Who listens to 45 minutes of preaching every Sunday?

And then I remembered that back in the day, I used to listen to upwards of 3-4 hours of preaching every Sunday.

I have to wonder if there’s a correlation between fearfulness and regular church attendance. I mean, I’ve grown in love and peace so much in this past year and I have to say: not hearing fear-inducing sermons has gotta be part of that, no?

On the other hand, I’ve been going to Mass more often. Which–I know this sounds contradictory–but it doesn’t feel like “going to church.” Maybe it’s because Mass is just so different. More Scripture reading, more reflection, more contemplation–less preaching. And above all, the Eucharist.

I’ve also discovered different ways of praying. I’ve found great solace and comfort in saying the Rosary, in silent contemplation, in prayerful breathing exercises.

If anything, this past year has shown me all the ways I can find God outside the walls of a church. The love of God is boundless. And by that I mean–the love of God is so big that nothing can bind it.

Not even the walls of a church. And it is this–this boundless, everlasting, all-compassionate love of God–that has made me more human.

More alive.

And even……happier.

This entry was posted in Catholicism, Faith, RecoveringFundamentalist, Religion. Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://remnantofremnant.blogspot.com/ priest’s wife

    It’s really interesting reading about your journey- and yes- a homily of more than 10-15 minutes would be really strange at a Catholic Mass

  • KatR

    I think that is why I felt such a sense of betrayal….I kept going to church, I kept studying my Bible, WHY WASN’T I HEALING!!! They were like talisman, and I couldn’t understand why they weren’t working. It took me awhile to figure out that I had to go a different route to find peace.

  • Upsidedown Kate

    Years after evangelical Sundays, I found that I just couldn’t do church any more. But I never felt right not going. So after awhile, I visited my grandparent’s church – the Catholic church. Five years and RCIA later I’m confirmed and peaceful. The mass is beautiful and I feel like I’m communing with God there.

  • http://twitter.com/dazeofadventure dazeofadventure

    “The love of God is boundless.” #AMEN
    thank you so much for this post. i love your transparency –
    happy new year to you !

  • Amespin

    Yes, Christian superstitions are to be avoided, but don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater.  There is truth to the lack of religious attendance and falling behind in Bible reading that can slant a person’s mind to a less Christ-like perspective of the world, which in turn has the potential to unwittingly invite evil.   Again, that’s not to say we should live in paralytic fear of the devil either.  As St. Teresa of Avila said, “People cry ‘the devil, the devil!’ when they should be saying ‘God! God!” and put the devil to flight.”  We shouldn’t be reading the Bible or attending Church just for what we get out of doing such things.  The spiritual benefits and defenses against evil are just means to God’s ends of encouraging us to do that which is good. It ought to be done as an act of love and prayerful attentiveness for our God and neighbor, and sometimes doing the loving and attentive thing just ain’t easy on our personal preferences. Do the loving and attentive thing any way.

    • Anonymous

      If I was going to throw the baby out with the bathwater, I would have become an atheist.

    • Hippie Gramma

      I don’t get how your explanation is any different than Christian superstition.
      If we make one wrong move — BAM! — God leaves us to fend for ourselves in a world (He created, by the way) of evil.
      If we take time to find ourselves spiritually — BAM! — the devil will move in and steal our souls.
      We must constantly be on guard against the world full of evil, or our puny God won’t be able to help us.
      Doesn’t sound any different than “knock on wood” to me.

      • http://outofthesilverchair.blogspot.com/ Botwejul

        I like that! Good reply Hippie Gramma….That puny god I have had to prop up for years with good works and butt loads of fear…

  • rebecca

    wow. can’t wait to show the post to my husband. we have been on and off church attenders for the last year. and i have to agree – the less i go the happier i am. the kinder i am. the less RELIGIOUS i am. i have finally reached the conclusion – i don’t want to be like the average person found at church. and that bothers me. (i know.i know. there are many people who attend church and are perfectly wonderful people. not critizing anyone who wants to go to church.)
    sometimes the junk that gets thrown from the paster is just crazy! i look around and wonder “really. no one else thinks thats nuts!”

    my biggest concern is; how do i keep my kids from becoming the neighborhood mission project? seriously.

  • http://thehomespunlife.com Sisterlisa

    Often times when people leave severe mind controlling churches, they do end up drinking…to self medicate from their trauma. However, that’s not because ‘leaving church leads you to sin”, but rather leaving a cult makes you aware of how messed up it made you. And dealing with the withdrawals can be quite daunting. The contemplative prayer sounds lovely…like breaking up the monotony of the typical Jesus prayers that many other churches teach.  I see no problem with the Rosary, some people walk labyrinths. For me, it’s being alone in nature..just breathing in the fresh air and listening to nature. Breathing deep and slow. I went to a Christmas Eve service and it was the first church service I had been in …in over a year. It was nicely done…but I have no desire to go back to going three times a week. I am free and finding community among fellow citizens that live in town. What i’m finding is that I’m not the only one who is on this journey.

    • Anonymous

      Love this, Lisa. And breathing deep in nature. Yessssss. Ahhhhh.

  • http://www.faithpermeatinglife.com Jessica @ FaithPermeatingLife

    I was raised Catholic, and even though I have serious issues with some of the teachings of Catholic leaders, I will continue to call myself Catholic and go to church because I love the Mass. It is where I find God, in a way unlike any other church service I’ve attended.

    That said, it is still possible for the priest’s 10-minute homily to be closed-minded and fear-mongering. We are incredibly blessed to have a wonderful pastor at our church whose homilies are challenging but loving, that actually make sense and propel you to action. I might feel differently about going to church if I felt attacked and angry every week.

  • Diana Trautwein

    Is not the mass said in church? Or are you defining ‘church’ as the building that houses a 45 minute sermon in Protestant, fundamental and/or evangelical circles? Seems to me that going to mass IS going to church. So maybe I’m just not understanding how you’re using the word in this context. I am delighted that you’ve found new ways to worship God that are helping you to heal from an abusive background. But it sounds to me like you are still finding comfort/community/worship in church after all. It just happens to be a Catholic one. 

    And there are lots of Protestant, liturgical churches where a 15 minute sermon/homily is the norm rather than 45 minutes. You are right, sometimes church communities can devolve into country club gatherings – but surely not all?? I’ve been both a churchgoer and a pastor in my life and I’ve seen both sides of this coin. And if you’re in a church where your own ability to live a peaceful, centered life that is connected through-and-through to God is compromised, then by all means – go elsewhere. And it reads as though that is what you’ve done. You haven’t stopped going to church, you’ve stopped going to a certain kind of church. Is that an accurate statement?

    • Anonymous

      I’m the using the word as in attending a particular place at a particular time with regularity. That’s what I’m not doing anymore.

      I go to Mass when I can but mostly I’m developing my relationship with God outside the walls of any church–whether Protestant or Catholic.

      And this is what makes me sad: what you took away from this post is that I didn’t define the terms according to your satisfaction? That’s pretty much exactly the kind of difficulty I’ve had inside conventional church: instead of honoring each person’s unique journey, we nitpick over definition of terms. We nail each other against the wall and demand “accurate statements.” I know this because I’ve done it many times myself. But I’m trying to move away from all that because what I realize is that by demanding that everyone speak the exact same words in the exact same way, we are in danger of missing the entire point of their story.

      And I feel that’s what you’ve done here.

      • Jack Isaacks

        One of the purposes of definitions is to make sure the participants in a conversation understand each other.

      • Chris

        I have to say that it threw me also; I immediately thought you’d left the Catholic church.

      • Chris

        Diana was gentle and seeking understanding; you were pretty harsh on her.

      • Diana Trautwein

        I am truly sorry if this feels like nitpicking to you – that was not my intention. I was quite honestly confused by the title of this post after I read it. I, too, am a questioner by nature. And I was asking you a question. That is all I meant to do.

        • Anonymous

          My apologies for misunderstanding the intent of your question. I mistook it for a ‘baiting’ question. Thanks for your sincere contribution to this thread. I’ll consider your words carefully. :) ((hugs))

          • Diana Trautwein

            Thank you, EE. If I comment in future, I will try to avoid anything resembling ‘baiting.’ :>)

            Someone’s later comment that the language ‘go to church’ is Protestant language was helpful. I do hang out with a great group of charismatic Catholics (they’re training me to become a spiritual director) and I go to mass regularly when we’re together. And I LOVE it a lot. 

  • http://faithandfood.morizot.net/ Scott Morizot

    I’ve been through so many changes over the course of my life that I’m often in the strange situation of present-me being in a situation where I see past-me and wonder at the difference.

    Peace.

  • http://beneaththesurface-dawn.blogspot.com/ Dawn Paoletta

    I appreciate your authenticity. Personally I do not believe, God is bound by any denomination. I really like how E. Elliot states “If God were small enough to be understood He would not be big enough to be God”. He is a mysterious, amazing and yet human God. He is mighty and beyond comprehension, yet as near as the breath. He meets us where we are, because He is merciful and faithful and sovereign. There is no perfect church, or people.He, himself  is the safe passage. Wishing you safe journey.

    • http://likesunshineinthehome.blogspot.com/ Sarah H

      I love that quote! I’m adding it to my collection. :)

  • Lynne Hallman

    i hate getting triggered in church.  i’m finding it so much more peaceful at a lutheran liturgy than at evangelical services.

  • Hippie Gramma

    Only once in my life have I been to a Protestant church where the sermon was 45 minutes.  Three to four HOURS?  Every week??  I think that ought to be on a list somewhere of red flags indicating a cult.

    I just made the final move to stop going to church.  I expected to feel free, but you know what?  I missed it.  Not the church as I left it, because it wasn’t healthy for me anymore, but the church as I remembered it, and wanted it to be.  We didn’t go on Christmas Eve and I really missed that.

    On the other hand, I am way too old and tired to deal with all the BS anymore.  I’ve gotten to where I can’t find God in ANY church, and come away feeling worse than when I went.  I’m really hoping my time away lets everything settle enough that I can gather the strength to find my way back.

    I’m so happy you’ve found a way to peacefully commune with God!  I would so love to get to the same place. 

  • Momma in Progress

    I love this post, and I relate to a lot of what you wrote. I also stopped attending church regularly about a year ago, and the difference has been very positive for me. There have been times in my life when I ONLY attended mass, because it WAS a different experience for me, not “church-like” even though I most definitely still considered it “going to church.” The last Protestant church I attended was a Lutheran congregation, small, personal, loving. We don’t live anywhere near there anymore, and we’ve never been able to replicate that feeling of community with any other church. So, we’ve sort of stopped trying. I don’t know if/when we will look for another place to worship (the inside four walls with other people kind of worship). Personally, in the last year I’ve been praying and reading the Bible and just *being* with God so much more than I ever did when I was showing up every Sunday.

    • Anonymous

      Momma in Progress: wow!! I had no idea! All this time I had tagged you in my mind as a commenter who got frustrated with me when I shared my concerns/experiences about Protestant churches. :) Let’s grow together. ((hugs))

      • Momma in Progress

        2012, year of surprises, eh? Truthfully, you do frustrate me tremendously sometimes, but in a good way? :-) In a challenging, ah EE is making me think again! sort of way? I want to keep reading about your journey, and I think we probably have more common ground than I originally thought. Hugs right back.

  • Servant of Christ Alone

    Yes God is not a building but the Bible does state that we are not to forsake the assembling of ourselves as the manner of some is. That is where I find the command as a believer in Christ to find fellowship and encouragement with other believers as we worship God through the preaching of His Word and through prayer. But too often I believe that we are looking through peace through ourselves and not in the power of the gift of Christ by salvation by grace through faith in Christ and him alone. While some churches may take away from this I as college student training for the pastorate find it of utmost importance not based upon man’s opinion or words but by the perfect Word of God to find my foundation for regular church attendance to aid in drawing me closer to Him and not necessarily this “peace” that most are looking for/putting their trust in. For even when the feeling is gone away I know based upon my knowledge and relationship with Christ that He is the Perfect Peace even though I may not “feel” like it.

    • http://likesunshineinthehome.blogspot.com/ Sarah H

      The trouble is we ASSUME the Hebrews scripture means a church meeting as it has traditionally become:  A large group of people all sat in rows looking in the same direction listening to one man speak for a long time to a captive audience on what he believes God is saying, sing a few songs, listen to someone pray and then go home.

      As far as I understand the word church itself means ‘assembly’.  So when we are told to assemble and meet together we can only speculate what the author of Hebrews had in mind.  Did he mean a church meeting as we understand it today?  Did he mean don’t neglect to BE church? – we ARE the ‘assembly’ after all.

      The church is a body of believers and we do need each other, but in much more ways than just sat in a church at certain set times.  That isn’t church.  Church is the believers.  We all need each other – so the preacher who gets the most air-time in ‘church’ isn’t necessarily living the scriptures because it isn’t just about the preaching – it’s about BEING the church with all that that entails. Preaching and teaching (which have become the dominating aspect of the church service) are just a tiny part.

      We are also meant to (as a church) use the gifts of: exhortation, giving, leadership, mercy, prophecy, service, teaching, administration, apostleship, discernment, faith, healing, helps, knowledge, miracles, tongues, tongues interpretation, wisdom, evangelism, pastoral, hospitality, and I am sure there are more.  You can’t do all of this in the context of just sitting in church for a ‘Church Service’.

      It’s not about THE meeting, it’s about meeting together to live the ‘one another’ scriptures. Love one another, wash one another’s feet, honour one another, instruct one another, greet one another, be patient with one another, submit to one another, forgive one another, serve one another, bear with one another, admonish one another, encourage one another, build one another up, confess your sins to one another, pray for one another,  offer hospitality to one another.
      Sorry rather long comment.

    • Anonymous

      As a college student training for the pastorate, don’t you have a vested interest in persuading people to regularly attend a specific place of worship? Your future job depends on it. And for the record, I haven’t “forsaken” the Body of Christ–I actually find myself drawer closer to it now that I’m not bound to specificity of geographical location.

    • Hippie Gramma

      “the command as a believer in Christ to find fellowship and encouragement with other believers…”

      Not a command; just a request, Tim…

      • Servant of Christ Alone

        forsake not is not a please dont it is just as it says forsake not and yes I have a vested interest but I also want to see a more active involvement in church worship beyond a preacher preaching (my job is merely to provide from scripture the commands that Christ has given and encourage the congregation to serve Christ actively as individuals and not just let the few in the church serve.) And I am basing my view on the local church based upon examples given throughout scripture of believers coming together for the preaching and reading of scripture.

  • http://www.facebook.com/jambotodd David Todd

    This makes me sad. God loves His church very much and whilst we’ve often made her ugly and whored her out, God is making her beautiful. His love for her is indeed unconditional. 

    It’s pretty easy and it’s pretty lazy to knock a flawed institution, full of sinners and hopeless cases, people just like you and I, but God has ordained the church to be His plan to demonstrate His love to the world. When people who obviously love God put the church down it makes me very sad.

    It’s especially dumb in that you haven’t left the church at all. What you do here is church, you bring your gift to your sisters and brothers here. You are a prophetess, you bring God given wisdom and insight and revelation. So you don’t fit the mould? Good, neither did pretty much every prophet in scripture, neither did Jesus!

    Just don’t abandon the church, she needs you, she needs people like you, so make this a sabbatical time and bring your gift back into God’s family. And when you do, be the woman God made you to be, not the woman you or anyone else thinks you should be.

    • Anonymous

      Thanks, David, for your thoughts. I never thought about the idea that what I do here on my blog is church–that’s an entirely new definition of church, yes? :)

      • http://www.facebook.com/jambotodd David Todd

        It’s church inasmuch as people gather here (albeit virtually (I hate that word)), discuss, learn, listen, consider God’s word even. There are other markers of church that we don’t really achieve, we don’t break bread or baptise, but I have no doubt that other sacramental things happen around your blog, prayer, spiritual growth. 

        We are all church and I think when we extend God’s Kingdom, which your thoughts and insight do, then we’re doing church. It’s maybe not complete, but it’s part of it.

    • Mccarthy83

      I love what you wrote David. It’s just sooo hard to return to church, fully open, insulated, not isolated when you have been (intentionally) and unintentionally scarred by it’s people. As much as I hate the victim mentality, sometimes we truly are the victims of other people’s insecurities. When these people are powerful, influential people, INTENTIONALLY coming against you and attacking your character without truth, the emotional damage can be devastating. Yes, I know God is in control, but it doesn’t make the resolution any easier.

  • http://bobregnerus.com/ Bob Regnerus

    I love you exposed your heart in this. This has been my experience as well, Elizabeth, and I and my wife found our real selves outside the context of the membership and regular meeting. This has inspired some people and offended others. It truly doesn’t matter – what matters is that we’re real with God and relating to him in the way we feel led to in our hearts and staying true to that. For some regular attendance is what they need for a time and maybe forever, but more are being courageous to pursue their hearts and develop a more intense and real relationship with God outside the walls and find God and themselves in the process. I know this strikes a major blow to “the church” but it certainly strengthens and builds “the Church” Jesus talked about.

  • Denise

    God simply wants us in fellowship with other believers, not necessarily in a church building on Sunday at 10a.m. I am so glad you are finding Him and His love outside of the rigid construct in which you were raised.
    I do, however, hope that at some point you can somehow distinguish the cult in which you were raised from the rest of us who identify as “Christian”. It isn’t fair to those of us who don’t beat people into submission with our bibles.

    • http://beneathhim.blogspot.com/ Amanda

      i agree most with this response – all except for the “it isn’t fair” part.  like you, denise, i’d like to feel as if we non-cultish, sincerely-trying-with-our-all-to-simply-follow-Jesus believers are being personally mistreated when we’re rolled in with the lump-sum-cult-church-wretched-institution-of-the-day; however.  Jesus did not defend Himself against the unfairness cast upon Him and if i am truly dying with Him daily (Galatians 2:20), then i, also, must not defend myself against such.  in my highest thoughts, i understand that there must be no ‘me’.

      again, i appreciate and agree with every bit of your comment with that distinction.  i sincerely hope that doesn’t come across like a criticism.

      elizabeth, i’ve only followed you for a short bit now.  i believe you are sincere and humble in your efforts to build a true relationship with God.  i believe that most of the other participants here are just as sincere.  forget buildings and organized religion.  we, the believers, the disciples – we are the church.

      • Anonymous

        I think this is a good point, Amanda. Whenever Christians do something that is horrible, I find that my immediate response is to say: well, that’s not ALLLLLLL Christians. What empathy is teaching me is to understand that we are ONE. i AM my brother’s keeper. When one member hurts, I hurt. When someone hurts someone else, I need to examine ways in which I am complicit in causing hurt. Thank you for your thoughts, here. They sparked some new thoughts of my own.

      • Denise

        No offense taken, and I actually considered leaving that part out. However, I do see it as being just as prejudicial/bigoted as any other stereotype. I dislike being lumped in with the Pearls and Campings of the world.

        Jesus may not have defended himself against unfairness, but I am not Jesus—try as I may to follow his example to the world.

        Blessings to you.

  • theresaEH

    When Catholics go to Mass we go to a Church! (God willing) when we to to Mass we go for the Eucharist, for something that was instituted by God for man.  The Eucharist is the body and blood, soul and divinity of our saviour Jesus Christ under the appearance of bread and wine. He is the divine physician to where we should go to when it hurts and when we are happy.

    • Anonymous

      Yes! I go to Mass for the Eucharist. For me, this is much different than simply attending church.

      • ARM

        This post made me notice something interesting: yes, Mass happens in a church, so it could be called “going to Church,” but in point of fact, we Catholics usually say “going to Mass” rather than “going to Church.” 

        • CE User

          Isn’t this because we don’t go to be with other congregants but are actively participating in the sacrifice and worship of God in the Holy Trinity with other congregants? It’s so much more than warming the pew. It’s being part of heaven and the eternal liturgy. Even if there is a poor sermon/homily, we still receive Jesus in the Holy Eucharist. Just give me Jesus.

        • Chantal

          I’ve had Masses outside. You can have a Mass without the building.   It just so happens that it is in a building.  Our winters are cold. I’m glad there is a building to protect me from the elements.I was curious about your post, but your use of church didn’t confuse me as I remembered a previous post where you mentioned that Church to you was what you grew up with.

          I am complete in Mass.  Like you, I find peace, healing and unconditional love.  It is God touching me personally.  

  • http://www.jimmyroman.com Jimmy Roman

    I was a worship pastor for 4.5 years at  a church. I was pushed out in a way because I had some disagreements with what they were doing. I left a year ago and I feel the same as you. I feel free. Free from fear and guilt and I help out more in my community by serving the oppressed and unwanted. 

    Quite honestly, leaving church was the best thing for me. I love God more now than I ever did before. When I was working at this church they pushed quite a bit of fear on me. It’s quite terrible. I hope others will see the same thing soon and finally flee the oppression. 

  • MPQ

    Kind of like when so many people righteously like to think in themselves as liberated, the old “I’m spiritual not religious”.  There is only one place on earth that every Sunday and each and every day, Christ doesn’t share with us only in spirit, but in His earthly Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity.

    Some find liberation not at the Miracle, but in their liberated spirituality.

  • http://ifmeadowsspeak.blogspot.com/ tammy@if meadows speak

    I think people find it hard to imagine church without identifying it, or you, with some denomination or building. If you have church in Spirit and Truth outside the system of programs, pastors, various meetings, and such, then defining it again and again may happen often. Besides, I’ve found most traditional church meetings are about each family member going to a different class room and church being about showing up regularly for attendance. From what I’ve been seeing happening across the States, those that have left the buildings are finding they’re able to freely operate with the head being fully Christ, instead of a lead pastor. Rarely, have I seen church, that is held in a building, able to operate this way nor could they. Sometimes it’s a long process of stepping outside of tradition and into the unknown, even if we have the New Testament church as our example.

  • http://honestlyadoption.blogspot.com/ Kim Van Brunt

    Thank you so much for this. It helps give voice to many things I’ve felt before and after leaving regular church attendance a couple years ago. Have you read “Mere Churchianity?” Like this post, the book made me say “exactly!” and freed me from the self-induced guilt I felt for leaving traditional church services on Sunday mornings. Now we have a small community of families on our same path that we meet with regularly for intentional conversation. I love where we’re at right now, and I have no interest in attending church services anymore — not even for the children.

  • http://www.downtoearthwomen.blogspot.com/ Tracey

    I am coming to see regular church service as something in ADDITION to a relationship with God. Quite frankly, my relationship with God is between Him and me and the fewer people around who think they have a right to meddle in that, the better. 

    I haven’t been to church in about 7 years. I was a faithful goer to that point. At my last church, I was a worship leader.

    I was informed I was no longer needed on the team. And then after that, my soon-to-be-ex who had assaulted me in front of my five kids and had been charged with 2 felonies in connection, was going to be allowed to come to my church. I asked the leadership to please not allow it, particularly since their mission statement read in part, “….a safe place of family worship….” but they said he had a right to be there and unless I could provide a restraining order, they wouldn’t do anything.  This was after the previous order had expired.  He was only going because he knew it would bother me. 

    I went one time after that and that was for my son’s funeral. I would have liked to have it somewhere else, but I didn’t know where else to do it. I belonged no where and his funeral made that knowledge even worse. 

    I would like to join another church, but I find the task so daunting. I want to belong pretty much for the community-only and fellowship aspect that’s a bit more meaningful than hanging with people at the bar or high school ball game. 

    I don’t know what I am going to do about that. 

    • Handsfull

      Tracey, I am horrified at your old church’s response to your situation with your almost-ex.  They were totally insensitive and lacking in compassion to you and your kids.  They should have protected you, and they didn’t.  I’m glad you left there… and I understand that it could take a long time to heal from that whole situation.
      But I hope that you do find the courage to try again.  It sounds like you’re missing some of the good things about church, so maybe it’s time to try again… :)

  • http://leannesmusings.wordpress.com/ Leanne

    After 10 years of eye-ball deep church involvement (including being on staff at two churches), my husband and I are taking it very slow.  Yes, we go to a church.  But we have been there 6 months and have not become “ministry leaders” [a record for us!]…we have no problem missing the occasional service to spend time with each other or friends [best quote ever by friends were were visiting a few weeks ago, upon realizing that we had talked and laughed for so long we were missing church: "Well, we can read a verse or something if that would make us feel better."]…and are really working on seeing the church as a body of believers who meet together to encourage one another – not as a project or organization that we need to “commit” to.   Meaning, of course, “getting involved” in two or more ministries.  We haven’t STOPPED attending – I love starting my week out in worship – but we have been slowly changing our perspective and taking this time in our lives to just rest and relax and not feel pressured to “do.”  It’s all about grace…I don’t need to earn God’s favor by serving on a committee or planning an event or working in kids’ ministry [and I say this as a former children's pastor...lol!!]….He loves me no matter what!  Blessings to you as you also pursue His love and grace – however you need to do it!!!

  • Carrie

    Elizabeth, please answer this because I SO want to know…How do your children handle you not going to church?  I want to stop going, but it upsets my children very much.  They get angry and unhappy with church.  I desperately want to find another church to attend, but my husband says we have to wait at least six months (because by then it will be a year since I started expressing a desire to worship elsewhere).  How do you explain your issues with church to your children?

  • Maryann

    Oops, I am not used to this newer comment format and posted my reply without getting a chance to preview. I pray that you don’t regard my previous note (saying that we’re obligated to attend Mass) as judgmental. But as a Catholic, I felt compelled to share the precept, since it’s something a lot of Catholics don’t seem to be aware of.

  • Lucie

    “It’s an ironic thing, really. Christians eschew superstition, but they can be pretty superstitious about what happens after you stop regular Bible reading and regular church attendance.”  SO TRUE!!

  • Handsfull

    I’m interested that so many people have said that since they stopped going to church their relationship with God has improved, they’re praying and reading the Bible more.  I wonder if it has something to do with feeling solely responsible for your relationship with God, instead of having a minister/pastor to – in some way – tell you how/what to do.  So now that that authority figure isn’t there anymore, YOU have to do it yourself.
    Kind of like when you leave home – often people start actually doing the things their mothers had to nag them to do before.
    Does that make sense?  Not trying to sound condescending or anything, just wondering…

  • http://www.matternfamily.com Rambling Heather

    Oh WoW what a post.  I love reading and seeing that other people are walking alongside a similar path.  We left church almost four years ago and I’m learning just now what this great Love looks like.

  • http://cuppboard.blogspot.com Elizabeth Erazo

    i am learning so much from you. Some of the confusion concerning Mass v. church is because of a lack of understanding of the Mass and the Catholic concept of Church. 

    From what I’ve experienced in Catholicism (which I admit is not much) it seems you do not go to Church – the Church is Christ’s Body, and you don’t go to Christ’s Body – you ARE Christ’s Body, you ARE the Church. You go to Mass, which is a particular form of worship to the Head of that Body. In that context, “going to Church” doesn’t make sense, because you are always in the Church. 

    Hope that makes sense! 

    On the flip-side, I am one of those who say “I stopped going to church, stopped reading the Bible, and all sorts of nasty started happening”, but what I mean when I say this is I made bad decisions, which were started by one major bad decision: to ignore God and shut Him out of my life. That decision was made first sub-consciously, then I dropped Bible & church, then the decision was made consciously. 

  • Sabahmom

    There is so much about your journey that is similar to mine. I love evesdropping on yours through your blog. I am on a “break” from the large Baptist church where I attend, with the intent of finding God, finding myself, becoming HUMAN, as you said. Not that the church is “what is wrong” with me, but over the years it had become a barrier to that process for me, rather than facilitating it – surely as much due to my history and what I brought to it. Taking this break has allowed some of those noisier voices inside me to quiet down, to the point that I’ve even been back a number of times recently – because I have truly WANTED to go. That in itself has been a wonderful change. I went to Mass for the very first time recently, too. And I have been back a few times. I am not sure where things are going to lead right now, but I’m experiencing more more ressonance between my desires and what I actually do than I have in many, many years. And I’m finding that to be life-giving. Very life-giving. Beginning to breathe again. Instead of feeling choked and stifled and afraid to move. Hard to explain unless you already “get it” – and I think you do. Sure appreciate your transparency and sharing your journey with us.

  • Mccarthy83

    It saddens me that I can relate to so much of what Elizabeth has written. Truly the deepest pain I have experienced has come from ‘Christ centered’ evangelical Christians. Never do I want to ‘throw the baby out with the bath water’. But I too, like sooooo many others, am questioning regular church attendance. I love the Lord, it’s just so many of His people that I’d rather not expose myself too!

  • Lindsay

    similar background here. I felt so guilty when I stopped going for a long time. Finally, when I was ready, I started looking for a healthy church and it’s been healing, though definitely a process. I haven’t been able to pick up my Bible in a really long time though. I had the same myths told to me about what would happen if I didn’t read it daily. (So far, I’m still alive :) ) I do want to be able to read it again, just not compulsively and with this kind of magical thinking about it. One day!