How the experts ruin everything from enjoying a hobby to practicing religion

My "after-sitting-in-silence" face.

For the first time in my long slog out of abusive religion, I’m finally finding spirituality that fits: sitting still, learning the language of silence. It’s taken me almost ten years to get here. But I can feel it now, that settling, these deepening roots. I can hunker down into the stillness and just be.

It’s funny, though. No sooner do you find something that works, then you start hearing from people who want to help you improve on it. Make it better. Go deeper! Try harder!

Optimal functioning is something of an obsession. It’s like we don’t think we’re fully experiencing something until we’ve invested all kinds of time, energy (and money) into improving on something that wasn’t broken in the first place.

For example, nobody is content to be an Ugly Runner anymore–everyone has to start training for damn marathons and posting their race times online and fundraising for charitable causes and slapping little 13.1 bumper stickers on their cars. Everyone is into the whole “take it to the next level” thing and I guess that’s fine if running is your thing: but for me? That ruins everything.

If I tried to take running “to the next level” (ie. training for a marathon), I would start hating it. Becoming an expert runner would ruin my enjoyment of it. I am perfectly content to be an Ugly Runner, a hunching-up-the-hill jogger. I don’t need to monetize or charitable-ize my running. Also, I don’t need injuries–which is what seems to happen to a ton of people who take running “to the next level.”

The same goes for spirituality. I’ve done the whole 100%, sold-out for God thing. And all I got was constipation and an anxiety disorder. In other words, I got injured by taking religion “to the next level.”

Maybe if you’re a first-generation believer, going all-out is a necessary kind of purgation–a vital life-overhaul that helps reset the generational trajectory.

But if you’re like me and were born into high-demand religion, you’ve experienced soul burn-out. You’ve spent decades trying harder, working longer, volunteering more. Resting on the Sabbath? Ha.

It’s taken me ten years to untangle myself from the guilt of “not doing enough” for God. I was so tightly bound up in religious OCD that I was routinely wracked with guilt for having missed an “opportunity” to do more.

For those of us who have been wounded by intrusive religion, perhaps the most healing thing we can do for ourselves is to do less. As in, become slackers for Jesus. For us, actually resting on the Sabbath is something of a major revelation.

Just being able to bring my mind and heart to a place of quiet stillness is enough for me.

Indeed, taking this to the “next level” would ruin it for me. I would be right back where I began: pulse-pounding, high-alert religion.

Ah, yes. Silence is enough for me.

This is what it means to seek God perfectly…to entertain silence in my heart and listen for the voice of God…to have a will that is always ready to fold back within itself and draw all the powers of the soul down from its deepest center to rest in silent expectancy for the coming of God.–Thomas Merton, p. 71, “Seeds.”

 

This entry was posted in Faith, RecoveringFundamentalist. Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://heretichusband.blogspot.com/ Heretic Husband

    This reminds me of the “Chewing Magazine” Calvin and Hobbes strips. Calvin is an avid gum chewer and subscribes to a magazine for serious gum chewers. When Hobbes asks why, Calvin says something to the effect of “How can I quantify enjoyment without hard data?”

  • http://kathyharter.blogspot.com/ Kathy Harter

    This hits close to home… I habe had anxiety issues since i was a small child. As an adult i was diagnois with OCD. The sad thing is that you would think being a chrisrian would have helped but it only made it worse. The thought of not doing enough or doing something wrong and God being mad at me was a huge trigger to anxiety/ODC episodes. I am begining to realise the lies i have been taught and belived from spiritual leaders….it has been eye opening and liberating and painful. For the first timein my life, i am believing that I am completely loved and accepted by God and it is not connected to my ‘doing’. It is making all the diffence. I am noticing a huge relief in my OCD…huge. somedays i
    feel like i am hanging on for dear life but i am going to keep moving forward…this new freedom is to good to go back.

    Thanks so much for sharing EE… I find so much encoragment and comfort from yor words.

  • Mark S.

    You are onto an important thing here. The Lord’s day was meant for our relaxation and enjoyment as a gift from the Father of us all. Disclaimer here: I am not all that wise. My wife and I from fairly early in our marriage when our kids began to arrive decided to make Sunday our family day. We centered the day on Mass at late morning, had a big leisurely breakfast, ate a mid afternoon meal together, enjoyed NON WORK THINGS and spent the evening together watching a movie or a shared favorite TV show. The rest of my family thinks we are weird but after 37 years, it seems to be working and spreading to our kids’ families.  It is that day set apart in so many ways and we have come to revel in it.

  • Devon Van Essen

    This is really helpful–a great thought to start my morning.

  • Joanie

    “Like”
    Very much like!Truly, the harder I try the crazier it gets.
    Another post filled with wisdom, Elizabeth! Thank you for sharing your heart.

  • http://faithandfood.morizot.net/ Scott Morizot

    Try harder at stillness and silence? That strikes me as a somewhat nonsensical prescription for anyone, not just those recovering from a spiritually abusive and demanding environment. Stillness is something you learn to enter largely by learning to cease “trying” and gradually learning instead to “be”. It doesn’t come easily or naturally to any of us — at least not in my experience.

     

  • birdsong

    I’ve done the whole “sold out for God” phase too.  I got rid of all my possessions in my early twenties and lived like a nun.  I moved after college to another state specifically for the parish I have now been at for 20 years. (It was known for being a real Catholic Church that upheld all the churches teachings) I attended Mass 365 days a year and sometimes twice a day.  I owned no TV or car and worked part time so I could spent the rest of the time in prayer and works of service.  I lived an intense, rigorous spiritual life.

    I did receive much healing while I lived in such a cocoon.  Now silence is truly the way I experience God’s presence the most.  I actually live in the world now instead of hiding from it. 

  • KatR

    I have commitment chronic fatigue – I did so much attending and meeting and reading and studying and giving as part of church that if any group or activity starts piling on the demands, I shut down.

  • http://transformingseminarian.blogspot.com Mark Baker-Wright

    I’m pretty active as a Transformers fan (as anyone who’s read my blog finds out pretty quickly upon seeing the Bible-bearing Optimus Prime figure featured at the top of the page), and I definitely see the same trend there, as well. The line between being a fan of something and becoming so intense about it that it becomes more frustrating to be a part of it than to simply enjoy it is often hard to discern.

  • emily

    Did you have a hard time developing this discipline, or does it come somewhat naturally to you?  I find the idea appealing, but then the idea of actually SITTING STILL and being QUIET kind of freaks me out.  I think I’m afraid of what I might find in myself in the silence.  Noise and busyness (much as I hate them both) are great at masking problems.

  • Miles O’Neal

    When I met the Truth, he set me free. But I let others talk me into the  bondage of religion. When I got free again, I determined that never again will it be about rules. Only relationship.
    If you’re in love, you don’t really need the rules. It’s pretty obvious not to cheat on someone, not to steal from them, not to tell lies about them, etc. When I really learned how much God loves me, I was able to start really loving back. And when I realized God loves everyone else that much, I started loving them that way, too. Who needs rules? Not so much the lovers.

    • Truthseeker

       Miles, i love what you shared.

      ENE, I came ‘home’ 5 months ago when I found an unprogrammed ‘silent’ worship group of Quakers or Friends somewhat near me.  I had been exposed to them years ago, but found them stuffy then.  I wanted ‘more’ in a church service.  Not any longer.  I love this group!!!!!  It is a conservative group-there are all flavors-but not everyone dresses ‘plain’, which I love.  We sit in silence for an hour, though sometimes one or more persons may feel led to speak.  Sometimes no one speaks

      I don’t try to empty my mind.  I just meet with God in my mind, and whatever thoughts come to the fore, I address or mull over, etc.  When my mind is actively silent, the hour flies by.  On one or to occasions, my mind was passively silent, and the hour crept. 

      I have no desire for ‘church’.  It would seem so full of clutter to me now.  I love my twice-weekly meetings.  I am just as blessed by the ones when no one speaks as I am by the ones when people do speak.

      Yaaaaaay for you for finding silence!  I love Henri Nouwen also!!!!

      • Truthseeker

         I meant ‘EE’, not ENE. :)

  • Mara

    Try harder at silence. Uh-oh. I have “peace” cds. And one of them I refer to as “hard core”. Well, it is… kind of. The others are cheap walmart/dollargeneral birdie twitterpated little things that are nice… But not hard core. My son thought calling a peace cd ‘hard core’ was funny too. But it really is a good cd… It pulls the tension right out of my neck and shoulders which is what I need since my life doesn’t allow me to take a day of rest. Won’t get into that one right now. It’s something I’m going to have to work on.

  • ARM

    This is one of the reasons I really appreciate the distinction the Catholic tradition makes between the basic morality and religion necessary for everybody and the “counsels of perfection” that go above and beyond, and are good, but not obligatory.  It’s also why I find our obligations (weekly Mass, yearly Confession, etc.) liberating rather than oppressive, as many outside the church perceive them.  If somebody wants to go to daily Mass, fantastic, but the existence of the basic rules helps make clear that nobody needs to feel guilty about not doing so.  For me, anyway.

  • Mara

    One of the reasons that my life doesn’t allow me to take a day of rest is because I’m married to a man with Adult ADHD. You talk about stress inducing.
    In fact, back when the “Purpose Driven Life” book was all the rage I tried to read it. It was the worst possible book for me.
    The first chapter told me that it wasn’t about me.
    Well, no freaking kidding, it’s not about me.
    Anyone married to ADHD knows that it’s never about them. It’s about the person with ADHD (or bi-polar, or Border Personality Disorder, or whatever other disorder that plagues the human race). It’s about the person with the disorder and that disorder tying everything up in knots. I needed the book that said that I am allowed to take time to recover and take care of myself. That it’s not all about my husband’s raging, unmedicated ADHD.
    Just about throw “The Purpose Driven Life” across the room.
    Perhaps there are people who needed that message. I was not one of them. I had to learn that, actually, sometimes, it is about me and my needs. That God is actually concerned about the stress I’m under and the hyper-vigilance I’ve developed in order to cope.

    I guess what I’m saying is that I agree, EE. It’s not one size fits all. Those of us who have made sacrifice after sacrifice, we don’t need to learn how to do it or figure out how to do it harder or better. The selfish, self-centered person might need to hear that. Not those of use who have been beaten to death with it.
    There is a balance that is missed when people push for better, faster, harder, stronger in our relationship with God and assume that we are all in the same place. Those people need to get their misguided hands out of our spiritual business.
    It is between us and our God.

  • Anonymous

    Oh Elizabeth, you’re such a soulmate. I love this! I love Merton too. Not long ago Dave and I did a contemplative discussion group (oxymoron huh?) on Seeds of Contemplation. I just am so glad I found you in the universe. 

  • Jo Ann

    Just BE. He enjoys you as you are :)

  • http://grittygrace.com/ martha brady

    i’ve come to believe that we have this innate desire to earn our salvation.  (the tower of Babel, romans 1 are illustrations too)  

    the concept of grace and salvation being a free gift is abhorrent to our self-rightous hearts.  add to that, our American independence and you have a religion of competition that can never “enjoy” and appreciate our salvation and gift of forgiveness GOD has given us. 

    there is always something more we must do for GOD when in fact, our salvation is all a work of GOD.  of course, we have responsibilities as part of being in the family, but they have nothing to do with competition, being a “better christian”, etc.

    resting in Christ is much closer to what being a christian is all about than the frantic running after the new trends of the week that often involve “fixing myself up for Jesus”, not living out who He has made me “in Christ”.

    i love the metaphor of  being in the “family of GOD”.  it conveys the positives of a family.  
    1.we are joined by blood.  
    2.we are for each other.  
    3.even though we fight with each other at times, we would defend each other to death if they picked on one of our own.
    4.we work together.  each of us has different strengths and we learn how to use them together in the family for the good of all.
    5. we have mutual goals as a family in terms of what we want to accomplish.  (in real life, it is helpful to state them for clarity.)

    i know this is more hopeful and optimistic than real life, but we need to know what Scripture teaches re the Church so we not only get our expectations in order, but realize where we need the emphasis.  i speak as someone who has not had a choice for 40+ years on the church i attend.  it has been a challenge to get my expectations (VERY idealistic, particularly re the behavior of others) in line with both Biblical truth and reality (my behavior).  it has been a major cause of growth for me…along with a very understanding and encouraging husband who also challenges me with truth:)

  • Anonymous

    One of the things I have learned from my recent health woes is that no matter what the experts know best, there is only one person who is an expert on ME, and in the end that’s the expertise that matters most. 

  • Laura

    Oh, how I love this post. You hit the nail on the head, lovely. Our culture (specifically, i’m referring to western culture) tells us CONSTANTLY that we must DO MORE, BE MORE, GET MORE, HAVE MORE, MORE!, MORE! MOOOOORRREEEE!!!  And I want to just look at our culture and say, “No, thank you.” I think our Christian culture is guilty of that attitude as well. BE MORE for Christ! DO MORE for Christ! MORE MORE MORE! LOUDER! STRONGER! MORE FOCUSED! MORE MORE MORE!

    It’s exhausting. And, for me, it makes me feel less connected to Christ, to God, to my soul.

    I feel most like a follower of Christ and that God is right with me in a deep and profound way when I am doing the simple quiet things of daily life: helping someone at work; cleaning my apartment; listening to someone share something with me; praying; preparing food; listening to music; etc. (I guess I consider myself an Ignatian.)

    Besides, we all know how hard it is to hear and comprehend when things are noisy and busy and bustling. :-)

    Peace to you, my dear friend.

    xo,
    Laura